Feb 172014

(Our man BadWolf reviews the new album by Benighted.)

Extreme metal musicians traffic in abrasion. Part of the music’s appeal stems from its opposition to the traditional harmonies of western musical tradition (which persist well into popular music). I believe the downside to abrasive, dissonant sound is that, much like spicy food or drugs, the human brain builds up a tolerance to it. Metalheads can grow tired of what normal people would consider highly abrasive music (say, Arch Enemy) and move toward even ruder sounds (say, Pig Destroyer).

But there is one sound that even the most dissonance-starved metalheads often cannot stand: the high-pitched inhaled shriek. The pig squeal. The bree.

Perhaps I am an unconscionable addict. Consider me a fan of the bree. And my pusher man into pig land is vocalist Julien Truchan of French brutal death outfit Benighted, whose new album, Carnivore Sublime, has rarely left my earbuds this week. Truchan’s vocal talent is formidable in all areas—he growls deep, shouts loud, and does it all while enunciating better than many vocalists claiming English as a native tongue. He transitions between all of these styles with the fluidity of mercury suspended in a vial. Then again, so do lots of vocalists.

What Truchan can do like nobody else is bree. Whether they serve primary vocal duty, or accentuate some other style, his shriek pierces through all levels of noise. The man has elevated the mating cry of swine into art, in the way Mariah Carey did with her falsetto on her song “Emotions.”

Yes, I am suggesting that we call Truchan the Mariah Carey of death metal.

Only a talented band can support—and compete with—such a vocalist, and Benighted are more than up to the challenge. The group’s sound is rooted firmly in Carcass-inflected death metal. A typical Benighted song fills between three and four minutes with melodic riffs and numerous slam-and-breakdown-segments. While the individual members are all technically proficient, the songs never degrade into showboating. It’s a solid take on the death metal genre that has produced several good-to-great albums in the past few years (Aborted’s Global Flatline, and Benighted’s own Asylum Cave).

Carnivore Sublime doesn’t alter the Asylum Cave formula much. The songs still build themselves around one big hook (usually a huge Truchan vocal) and shred around it, the best example probably being the recurring “Nothing but decay!” counter-play that ends “Spit” (one of the strongest tracks on the album). Benighted have added a few elements to their repertoire, specifically the ball-busting gang vocals prominently featured in the lead single, “Experience Your Flesh,” and the opener “X2Y.”

Benighted’s sheer sense of voracity makes their take on the style compelling. A Benighted song careens forward like a test-flight rocket with a faulty engine. Their tunes take occasional breathers, like the tom-line-and-chanting intro to “Slaughter/Suicide,” but more frequently the songs sputter and hiss between more high-velocity segments. Carnivore Sublime feels like its trajectory could disintegrate any minute, and that’s the fun of it.

And fun’s the point on a Benighted album. While the band may have some sort of socially charged subtext to their lyrics, their work on Carnivore Sublime is perverse, and I don’t simply mean the nip-slip album art that got Benighted ejected from Facebook. There is a sense to their work that something more menacing, more twisted lies under the surface of it. That idea dovetails well with their barely-restrained take on brutal death metal. It’s not going to be heavy or technical enough for some, but Benighted, thanks to Truchan’s vocals and the group’s knack for hooks, make some of the most likeable brutal death metal out there.


Carnivore Sublime is out now on Season of Mist and can be ordered here. There’s a full album stream below, from Bandcamp, along with an official video.



  1. Amazing album!!! Their best!!! Love this review

  2. Full streaming and purchase available on bandcamp:


    I’m going to have to check this out now, even though I LOATHE the pig squeal.

  3. The piggy vocals I just can’t get past. Music is good, even great sometimes, but those vocals just grate on my ears like rusty nails on a chalkboard.

  4. “What Truchan can do like nobody else is bree.”

    The palpable irony is that when he “brees” he sounds EXACTLY like everyone else.

    I’ve always thought of the pronunciation/annunciation of a vocalist as being their equivalent to a guitarist’s tone/tightness, something which helps make them distinct, even though they’re operating in a specific area (death vocals, etc) – and “bree-ing” is one of the most repetitive, monosyllabic and indistinguishable vocal “styles” there is. There might as well not be lyrics, and heck, the vocalists themselves become interchangeable.

    Still, I like the album.

  5. Not usually a fan of the pig vocal,but there’s so much variation in what he’s doing with his voice here that I can overcome it. Really does remind me of Aborted and Cattle Decapitation’s last albums,with a touch of Carcass on top.Great review-I normally would’ve gone right by this album,but now I’m buying it!Thanks!

  6. sounds awesome, that’s a double nipple album if i ever heard one

  7. As a card-carrying member of the bree fan club, i think the best squeals i’ve heard are on the first two Despised Icon albums. Also i believe Neuraxis approached bree territory on their older albums! Benighted sounds great as well. I think the vocal choice just adds to the abrasiveness of the music, and helps to separate the song sections.

  8. in my opinion phlegethon from wormed is the best BREE around. dude sounds like a giant alien cricket

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>



This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.