Nov 202026
 

(Here we present Gonzo’s review of a new album by Colorado’s Wayfarer, which is being released today by the Vesperian label.)

As is the case with any art form, pushing creative boundaries is a high-risk, high-reward endeavor. In metal, those boundaries can often live under the shroud of fanbase expectations, where gatekeeping and whatever artificial standards of “cvlt enough” become the defining narrative instead of the music itself. At times, this leads to a twisted perception in groupthink and premature opinions.

Bands that have crossed a certain sytilistic threshold know this all too well. Opeth is the most glaringly obvious with a few others following suit. And with the release of Riders of the Setting Sun, the black metal cowboys in Denver’s Wayfarer are the latest to dip their spurs in polarizing waters. They’ve effectively traded their more ferocious songwriting tendencies in favor of a stripped-down approach, creating a record that’s a far cry from its predecessors.

The big question that remains, though: Is the switch in sound a ride worth taking?


photo by Manon Hure

Let’s get to the point. With Riders, Wayfarer have taken the dark, dust-laden cinematic roots that have always defined their sound and used them in a much different way. Blast beats, tortured screams, and savagely fast tempos have been replaced by acoustic guitars, banjos, and something that nobody’s going to be quick to describe as “metal.” Fortunately, Wayfarer have the songwriting chops and self-awareness to understand how to pull this off.

If predecessor American Gothic was the soundtrack to a blood-soaked western apocalypse, Riders of the Setting Sun is the post-credits dirge for those who survived—and those who didn’t. Leadoff track “The Dusklands” opens with a bone-chilling spoken-word intro before heading straight into an upbeat stomp, showing off Isaac Faulk’s percussive versatility. Shane McCarthy’s lyrics tell another morbid high-plains tale that gets in your head quickly, perfectly setting up the rest of the album’s aesthetic.

You can practically feel the desert heat on your back during the dark twang of “Perdition’s Crossing,” released as a single earlier this summer. The addition of vocals from the ever-mysterious David Eugene Edwards of 16 Horsepower and Wovenhand are a natural fit for its haunting motif, and the same can be said for Munly J. Munly’s work on “Grey Country.” Sometimes, guest vocals can sound forced or even unnecessary, but the performances from both Edwards and Munly elevate those songs to another level.

Elsewhere, “Fell Spur” feels like a natural successor to “Reaper on the Oilfields” from American Gothic. It’s a deeply ethereal song that borders on hallucinatory, making you wonder if you’re seeing ghosts or a mirage somewhere along the horizon. When it all coalesces into the gorgeously written “Hollow Hearts on the Trail to Eden,” you begin to realize the scope of the journey you’ve been taken on. When the band debuted that song on the main stage at this year’s Fire in the Mountains, I instantly knew it’d be an album highlight, and I wasn’t wrong. It’s like going on a days-long hike and looking back at the road you’ve already covered, only to scratch your head and wonder how you ended up standing on top of the huge valley beneath you. It channels moments from Opeth’s Damnation in the best possible way. My only minor complaint is that the song fades away slowly instead of ending on a more distinct, defined moment, but maybe I’m missing the point.

When the dust finally settles on this voyage, no one would blame you for thinking Wayfarer have quietly crafted a new genre of music. Riders of the Setting Sun takes the best elements of gothic country, post-punk, folk, and the self-described Denver sound to create something that proudly stands on its own. It’s not going to be for everyone, and that’s okay. People looking for a sonic duplicate of American Gothic or A Romance with Violence (or anything else in the band’s vaunted back catalog) are going to be disappointed.

But if you set your expectations aside and surrender to the thrill of the unknown journey, Riders of the Setting Sun beckons you to saddle up.

https://linktr.ee/vesperian
https://www.instagram.com/wayfarercolorado
https://www.facebook.com/wayfarercolorado
https://wayfarercolorado.bandcamp.com

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.