(Here’s Part Two of Andy Synn’s five-part series on his reflections about metal albums released in 2014. His list of the year’s “Great” albums appeared here yesterday.)
What separates the truly “Great” from the merely “Good”? A variety of things really. Sometimes it’s not much at all. Some of these albums actually come within a hair’s breadth of achieving true greatness, while others stumble a little more obviously along the way.
It could be that they’re too long, or too short… too ambitious, or not ambitious enough… or just in some way lacking that singular spark which defines true greatness.
That being said, each of these albums is, in their own way, a damn fine listen, visceral, intense, and a worthy addition to anyone’s collection – just because they’re not defined here as one of the truly “Great” albums of the year, doesn’t mean they’re not very, very, good.
And some of these albums are definitely very good.
Case in point, albums from Entombed, Anaal Nathrakh, Taake, Earth Crisis, and Ghost Brigade all came this close to achieving true greatness, not quite touching each band’s best work – but not far off either – whilst very impressive debut albums from both Kall and Oubliette showcased each band’s distinctive and evocative take on Black Metal’s underlying principles, and hinted at a fantastic future for both bands.
Black Metal from the good old US of A was also well represented this year, with new releases from both Abazagorath and Krieg attracting a hell of a lot of attention, closely followed by the underrated Catharsis Absolute by Avichi, and I can’t fail to mention the uneven – yet undeniably compelling – semi-swansong released by Nachtmystium, or the brutish assault of Black Anvil either.
Going further afield, Deep Mountains and From The Vastland both put their own unique spin on the Black Metal genre, the former delivering a particularly captivating and brilliantly atmospheric debut, and the latter continuing to go from strength to strength with each release. AEvangelist continued to explore the outer limits of sonic horror (albeit, in a slightly less effective way this time around) with Writhes in the Murk, while 2014 also saw us receive a welcome helping of Blackened Death brutality courtesy of Noctem, Saille, and Necronautical.
Speaking of brutality, both Carnifex and Wretched vomited forth a heaving torrent of caustic aggression this year – both bands developing beyond their Deathcore roots in leaps and bounds – even as bands like Archspire, Origin, and Fallujah endeavored to push the Death Metal genre’s speed and technicality as far as humanly possible, with The Lucid Collective, Omnispresent, and The Flesh Prevails all gaining in sheer extremity what they might have lost in terms of hookiness and memorability.
The always vicious Benighted continued to mix lethal doses of grind into their rabid, ravenous approach to Death Metal with the unrepentant Carnivore Sublime, while Divine Chaos chose to augment their sound with a tasty helping of thrashy dynamism, keeping things fresh and ferocious in the process.
Devastating debut albums from Sidious and Tyranny Enthroned showcased precisely what both bands have to offer the world, and can sit proudly alongside albums by more established acts such as Hour of Penance and Vader, who both hinted at greatness with their new albums this year, without quite reaching the pinnacle of their deathly craft.
Illdisposed and The Morningside brought a heavy helping of Death Metal groove to the year, the former continuing their 20+ year career with seemingly no intent at slowing down or switching directions any time soon, the latter making a turn into choppier, more aggressive waters with their third full-length.
Both Cannibal Corpse and Mayhem produced solid additions to their punishing portfolios this year, and both Exodus and The Haunted staunchly weathered the loss (and return) of a vocalist to deliver their best albums in quite some time, firmly stamping down on the doubters and nay-sayers.
On the more melodic side of things, both Alcest and Anathema struggled a little between playing it safe and expanding their palette, although both still produced some extremely good albums despite this. Similarly both Evergrey and Scar Symmetry successfully added a few new touches to their established formulas, freshening their approach ever so slightly, even as they refused to rein in their particularly brash brand of shameless guitar heroics.
Demon Hunter continued along their well-worn, yet never uninteresting, path – producing another album that mixes together some absolutely killer material with an unnecessary amount of filler. By contrast, pseudo-tech-death prog-metallers Son of Aurelius twisted their entire sonic identity almost completely on its head with their new album Under A Western Sun, upping the progressive elements and clean vocals by a huge ratio, resulting in a truly compelling (if uneven) listening experience.
Speaking of Prog, Opeth took a lot more risks with Pale Communion than they did with Heritage, a decision which paid off handsomely in terms of the album being far more interesting and infectious than its predecessor, despite the occasional questionable choice or misstep.
Before I go on to briefly discuss a number of damn good EPs that have been released this year, I need to make mention of two other albums – one by Back to R’yleh and the other by KYPCK – that didn’t really fit with any of the other albums here. Both are strange in their own way, the former a weird amalgam of proggy experimentation and willful disregard for convention that goes to some very strange, very unique places, the latter an odd, depressing concoction of groaning Finnish doom that grabs your attention right from the start and refuses to let go, for better or for worse.
EP-wise, this has also been a really good year, with multiple forms of Black Metal (Khonsu, Pantheon I, Myrkur) and Death Metal (De Profundis, Nader Sadek) showcasing the variety of approaches within each genre, while more experimental works, such as the electronic soundscapes of Progenie Terrestre Pura, the crushingly claustrophobic, doom-shrouded atmospherics of Eye of Solitude, and the out-there progressive inclinations of Solefald, spanned the length and breadth of the metal genre.
Oh, and you should also check out the three-track EP by Swedish hardcore-types Riwen. You won’t regret it.
Tomorrow it’s time for the potentially (and probably) contentious list of the year’s most “Disappointing” albums. If you’ve not seen an album appear either today or yesterday… well, there’s a good chance it’s going to crop up on tomorrow’s list which, while much shorter than either of its predecessors, still contains some very prominent names.
You have been warned!
Anyway, here’s the complete list of the “Good” albums, for those of you who’ve stuck around this long!
Abazagorath – The Satanic Verses
AEvangelist – Writhes in the Murk
Alcest – Shelter
Anaal Nathrakh – Desideratum
Anathema – Distant Satellites
Archspire – The Lucid Collective
Avichi – Catharsis Absolute
Back to R’yleh – The Awakening / Last Flight of the Primordial
Benighted – Carnivore Sublime
Black Anvil – Hail Death
Cannibal Corpse – A Skeletal Domain
Carnifex – Die Without Hope
De Profundis – Frequencies
Deep Mountains – Lake of Solace
Demon Hunter – Extremist
Divine Chaos – A New Dawn In The Age of War
Earth Crisis – Salvation of Innocents
Entombed – Back to the Front
Evergrey – Hymns for the Broken
Exodus – Blood In, Blood Out
Eye of Solitude – Dear Insanity
Fallujah – The Flesh Prevails
From the Vastland – Temple of Daevas
Ghost Brigade – IV. One With The Storm
The Haunted – Exit Wounds
Hour of Penance – Regicide
Illdisposed – With The Lost Souls On Our Side
Kall – Kall
Khold – Til Endes
Khonsu – Traveller
Krieg – Transient
KYPCK – Имена на стене
Mayhem – Esoteric Warfare
The Morningside – Letters From the Empty Towns
Myrkur – Myrkur
Nachtmystium – The World We Left Behind
Nader Sadek – The Malefic: Chapter III
Necronautical – Black Sea Misanthropy
Noctem – Exilium
Opeth – Pale Communion
Origin – Omnipresent
Oubliette – Apparitions
Pantheon I – From The Abyss They Rise
Progenie Terrestre Pura – Asteroidi
Riwen – Riwen
Saille – Eldritch
Scar Symmetry – The Singularity (Phase I: Neohumanity)
Sidious – Revealed in Profane Splendour
Solefald – Norronasongen. Kosmopolis Nord
Son of Aurelius – Under A Western Sun
Taake – Stridens Hus
Tyranny Enthroned – Our Great Undoing
Vader – Tibi et Igni
Wretched – Cannibal
It’s called “The Lucid Collective.” I’m surprised neither that nor Son Of Aurelius were considered “great” albums, but it’d be boring if everybody agreed. Nice to see Carnifex, Demon Hunter, and The Haunted not tossed out simply because they’re Carnifex, Demon Hunter, and The Haunted.
Weirdly I got the album name right in the text… and wrong in the list.
From this I can conclude that… I am an idiot.
I was disappointed by Ghost Brigade (although still a a good record with some great trademark GB stuff) and more so by Hour of Penance( thought they just sounded very comfortable, paling in comparison to Hideous Divinity who hit a six out of the park).
What’s your take on the new Mors Principium Est?
I still haven’t got round to checking out HD or MPE unfortunately!
From whatever little i’ve heard its good but HD is ownage.
I agree with you about all three of those albums.
Progenie Terrestre Pura have a new album out? What have I been doing with my life?
Again, so much to look at, and so much I don’t know. I am surprised that I didn’t know about the Taake album.
I agree that the new Origin and Archspire albums are good, but not great.
Maybe sometime, after I get over myself, I’ll give the new Opeth album a listen. That will probably be sometime after 2028.
By which time it will be considered ‘vintage’.
And the Taake album has only JUST come out – hence why we’ve not even gotten around to reviewing it!
I pretty generally agree here. A lot of these were solid, but not quite amazing. I have many thoughts about the new Opeth, now that I’ve finally got around to it, but I’ll save that for my list.
Are they just “This is not Death Metal! This band are shit now!”?
Not at all. More along the lines of “I could care less if the growled vocals are still around, but I miss the heavier, more metal-y guitar tones Akerfeldt and crew used to use, providing a stark contrast to the softer parts, kinda like Face of Melinda or A Fair Judgment.” I plan to compare it to Soen (granted, I haven’t heard the whole album, only the few songs with music videos), who seemed to have a similar outlook, but with some metal-y parts still in there to contrast with the softer parts, or, in Opeth’s case, the softer and/or proggier parts. Without the presence of any metal at all (not just death metal – if that leaves forever, I’d be fine), the contrast that made me love Opeth gets diluted. Granted, I still think Pale Communion is a great album, and a better record than Heritage, but it is still hampered by the above.
Hopefully I wrote that cogently. Kinda stream-of-consciousness-ed that one, and it’s 1:30 in the morning, so I’m not feeling like making sure it’s cogent.
I think you nailed it with this list. Abazagorath was a nice addition and as much as I find myself listening to it, it was up against such crazy competition from the likes of Sinmara, Thy Darkened Shade and Nightbringer.
Especially nice to see Oubliettes name up there. On a top 10 of my favorite black metal, that was 11. It was super good and I find myself coming back to it a lot.
Nice work. I agree with a lot of this. I really looked forward to and really wanted to love the new albums by Aevangelist, Krieg, Black Anvil, Hour of Penance, and Anaal Nathrakh, but I don’t think I played any of them more than once.
The Noctem album is killer though, and the Taake album is really growing on me.
Am I the only person who listened to Omnihility’s 2014 release???
Though it is on my list of albums to catch up on!
Well written and well selected. I especially agree that Myrkur’s EP is good, but the atmosphere stuff is bit over the top. If she can just tighten things a bit more, it would be excellent for me. Still looking forward to the full-length.
Yeah, the idea of that full-length has my nethers all a-tingle.
great stuff : )
I pretty much agree 100% with you here…..a lot of really solid albums just shy of greatness. A lot of stuff I haven’t really heard of as well such as Abazagorath, Son of Aurelus, Deep Mountains, Saille and Necronautical.
I was also unaware that a new Taake album was out. I’ll definitely be checking that one out as well!
Most people seem unaware of the new Taake… which obviously raises some suspicions (a bit like how movie studios embargo reviews on movies they know are going to take a critical pounding).
But it’s actually really good. Not their best album ever, but definitely worth tracking down asap!