Dec 162014


Here we have yet another list of best metal albums of 2014 from yet another “big platform” web site, i.e., one with a large online audience that doesn’t cater mainly to metalheads. This time the list comes from Stereogum.

I’ve been waiting for this one, not because I thought it would be amusing in the way that lists from other such places are often amusing, but because there are some studs who put the Stereogum list together: The list was compiled by Michael Nelson, Ian Chainey, Aaron Lariviere, Wyatt Marshall, and Doug Moore.

To be clear, I don’t have any personal knowledge of their sexual exploits, but these are people whose opinions about metal I respect — their monthly Stereogum column, “The Black Market”, is one I always make time to read even when I don’t have time to read much of anything else in the sphere of metal writing.

As Michael Nelson explains in his entertaining and thought-provoking introduction to the list, it’s a result of compromise — the give-and-take among these five writers, not compromises dictated by editorial direction and pandering to readership demographics, which is the kind of smell I’ve gotten from a few other lists from other places that I’ve re-posted here.

He acknowledges right up front that the list is missing some names that many knowledgable fans would expect to see, not because the albums weren’t good, but because they didn’t survive the debate among the writers that produced the final compilation.

The list does include many of what I’ve come to think of as 2014’s “usual suspects”, i.e., good albums that seem to be appearing everywhere, including at a lot of those other “big platform” sites — Triptykon, Pallbearer, Behemoth, At the Gates, and YOB. Yet the placement is far from typical — only two of those albums are in the top 10, and those two are in the company of excellent albums by more obscure bands such as Nux Vomica, Horrendous, Thou, and Artificial Brain.

There are a lot of other things I like about this list. It gives recognition to many deserving albums that have been overlooked by most of the lists I’ve been seeing at other sites — Martyrdöd, Dead CongregationThantifaxath, and Sivyj Yar are in the top 20, and the top 30 includes Teitanblood, Slugdge, Diocletian, and Abigor. Good to see those names, and there are relatively unheralded gems spread throughout the rest of the list, too.

Yes, there are albums I wish I’d seen on a list of this length — off the top of my head, I’d name the ones from Spectral Lore, Thy Darkened Shade, Cretin, and Nightbringer (and I assume Solstafir was omitted because the writers didn’t think it was metal enough) — but that’s the nature of the list-making beast: The only list any of us will love from top to bottom is the one we make for ourselves.

Having said that, where da folk metal at?

Go here to read the Michael Nelson’s introduction and the explanations for each pick. Here’s the list:

50. Old Man Gloom – The Ape Of God (Profound Lore)
49. Piss Vortex – Piss Vortex (Indisciplinarian)
48. Ides Of Gemini – Old World New Wave (Neurot)
47. Psalm Zero – The Drain (Profound Lore)
46. Anguish – Mountain (Dark Descent)
45. Incantation – Dirges Of Elysium (Listenable)
44. Witch Mountain – Mobile Of Angels (Profound Lore)
43. Yautja – Songs Of Descent (Forcefield)
42. Ingurgitating Oblivion – Continuum Of Absence (Willowtip)
41. A Pregnant Light – My Game Doesn’t Have A Name (Colloquial Sound Recordings)
40. Triptykon – Melana Chasmata (Century Media)
39. Tombs – Savage Gold (Relapse)
38. Diskord – Oscillation (Hellthrasher Productions)
37. Sargeist – The Crawling Shadows (W.T.C. Productions)
36. Jute Gyte – Vast Chains (Jeshimoth Entertainment)
35. Krieg – Transient (Candlelight)
34. Brutal Blues – Brutal Blues (Nerve Altar)
33. Emptiness – Nothing But the Whole (Dark Descent)
32. Nasheim – Solens Vemod (Northern Silence)
31. High Spirits – You Are Here (Hells Headbangers)
30. Couch Slut – My Life As A Woman (Handshake Inc.)
29. Fluisteraars – Dromers (Eisenton)
28. Abigor – Leytmotif Luzifer (Avantgarde Music)
27. Diocletian – Gesundrian (Osmose Productions)
26. Slugdge – Gastronomicon (self-released)
25. Godflesh – A World Lit Only By Fire (Avalanche)
24. Teitanblood – Death (Norma Evangelium Diaboli)
23. Pallbearer – Foundations of Burden (Profound Lore)
22. Falls Of Rauros – Believe In No Coming Shore (Nordvis)
21. Giant Squid – Minoans (Translation Loss)
20. Gridlink – Longhena (Handshake Inc)
19. Panopticon – Roads To The North (Bindrune/Nordvis)
18. Sivyj Yar – From The Dead Villages’ Darkness (Avant Garde Music)
17. Behemoth – The Satanist (Metal Blade)
16. Thantifaxath – Sacred White Noise (Dark Descent)
15. Indian – From All Purity (Relapse)
14. Dead Congregation – Promulgation Of The Fall (Profound Lore)
13. Winterfylleth – The Divination Of Antiquity (Candlelight)
12. Martyrdöd – Elddop (Southern Lord)
11. Primordial – Where Greater Men Have Fallen (Metal Blade)
10. Artificial Brain – Labyrinth Constellation (Profound Lore)
09. Thou – Heathen (Gilead Media)
08. At The Gates – At War With Reality (Century Media)
07. Woods Of Desolation – As The Stars (Northern Silence)
06. Morbus Chron – Sweven (Century Media)
05. Agalloch – The Serpent & The Sphere (Profound Lore)
04. Nux Vomica – Nux Vomica (Relapse)
03. Horrendous – Ecdysis (Dark Descent)
02. YOB – Clearing The Path To Ascend (Neurot)
01. Blut Aus Nord – Memoria Vetusta III – Saturnian Poetry (Debemur Morti)

  18 Responses to “LISTMANIA 2014: STEREOGUM’S “50 BEST METAL ALBUMS OF 2014””

  1. “Blut Aus Nord”? That’s laughable! Gorguts put out the best METAL album this year – don’t deny it. Stop trying to be different – you’re only appealing to hipsters. Have fun with that. I thought i’d found a credible metal music site to frequent. Apparently not – laters!

  2. Fuckin stoked to see that Slugdge made a top 50.
    I’ve tried to read all of them here but maybe I missed one, however maybe I will finally be able to take one of these Top xx’s seriously. Blut Aus Nord was a bit out of left park for me though if I am being completely honest.

  3. Cool list as usual from the Black Market Activities section. And yes its one list that i too frequent.

  4. Finally someone puts Nux Vomica on their list. I seriously can’t comprehend how that’s flown under nearly everybody’s radar – but the pattern I’ve seen is that it’s either not there or really high up in the rankings of a list.

  5. There are definitely some lesser-known picks here; even a couple that I totally missed (Couch Slut). There isn’t much overlap with my list but it’s nice to see some love for Giant Squid and Anguish.

  6. This is a list I can get behind. Slugdge, as many have mentioned, is a nice addition. Definitely one of my top death metal releases of the year.

  7. I always enjoy seeing these lists. Stereogum’s is usually one of the better ones. By the way, it seems increasingly unjust that Ringworm is getting left off all the lists I’ve seen so far. Not cool. (Also, why no Gorguts? Laughable.)

  8. A few in here Im really curious to check out, but more and more the top albums are starting to become a bit predictable. Theyre almost guaranteed to include some variation of Blut Aus Nord, YOB and At the Gates (which I’ll say again, really wouldnt be best of the year worthy if that was any other band)

  9. Yes, Memoria Vetusta III is the best metal album released in 2014.

    Good to see Emptiness get a mention as well.

    I’ve really been surprised at how often Diocletian has been appearing on these lists. I listened to it again last night and, well, it’s just not that good.

    Also, has Horned Almighty’s “World of Tombs” made any of these lists? Great album.

  10. there’s some really good stuff on there : )

  11. Some great stuff on here however I completely agree with you on them not including Thy Darkened Shade, Cretin and Spectral Lore on here. Nonetheless this is a fantastic list

  12. That Behemoth album is one of the most boring albums I’ve ever heard, if it were anyone but such a mainstream band, no one would have rated it at all.

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>



This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.