(Wil Cifer reviews the new album by Deafheaven.)
Deafheaven are not the first black metal band to inject elements of post-rock and shoe-gaze into the mix, things that bands like Amesoeurs and Agalloch are praised for. Deafheaven did this without the use of clean singing as well. They became a point of contention with their 2013 album Sunbather. It was praised by the more mainstream press and found the band bringing their brand of so-called black metal to such questionable audiences as Bonnaroo. Accusations of the band being “Hipster Metal” flew on message boards everywhere.
Then there are those who could not put Sunbather on enough top ten lists and listed this new one as one of the most anticipated albums of 2015, before the band stepped into the studio. Can this album live up to the hype?
They open the album with atmospheric fanfare, before busting into a massive chug that makes you think they took the accusations of not being true enough metal to heart and are now daring you to say otherwise. It’s effective, but the first thing that caught my ear was how George Clarke has added more variance to his screams, which had begun to take on a monotonous static pattern by the time their second album rolled around. He has a lower and nastier, almost Dissection-like sneer to this rasp.
This is no longer a two-man show, with the band working as more of unit allowing for single-note guitar melodies to be layered over the more powerfully driven riffs. This is not to say they have given up on the clean guitar, as they do return to the more indie post-rock sound that is seldom droning enough to create the narcotic-like shoe-gaze sound. It works better here as a contrast to the flexing of the band’s metal muscle.
This album is darker; “Luna” finds Clarke shrieking less and instead using a more staccato lower growl over the sprinkling of blast beats. Speaking of blast beats, they do not have to rely on them exclusively because drummer Daniel Tracy is a crazy beast, able to throw intricate cymbal accents into the chaos and then drop down into death metal double-bass. He toured with the band for Sunbather, but seems like he was given free rein to be himself on this album.
At the six-minute mark of “Luna”, they break into a piano-littered post-rock passage that after three albums you have to know is coming. It’s the slower pound that is more impressive on this one.
There is a hushed start to the nine-minute “Baby Blue”. The blast beats do come calling, until the heavier, thrash-like chug bites into the song. The heavier turn the band have taken often demands they dumb things down to a more meat-and-potatoes approach to metal, but that doesn’t prevent them from ebbing back down into something that is more shoe-gazing. If they had forsaken the more ambient side of what they do, I would have felt it would have been more of a sellout than if they had put out an album that just wanted to be My Bloody Valentine all together.
The ten-minute “Come Back” indulges Deafheaven’s more delicate side before the metal kicks in. The big chords come very intentionally and they even throw in a very rock ‘n’ roll guitar solo that would not have surprised me as much if it had been on a Super Joint Ritual album. The third time still proves to be a charm for locking in on a chug with a hint of ’80s thrash to it. The final minute and a half is a dreamy sample of a traffic report similar to the samples found on the last album.
New Bermuda closes with “Gifts For the Earth”, which starts off with more ’90s emo-like guitar sound. Clarke’s rasp is a welcomed juxtaposition. Spoken vocals are placed way back in the mix, which are not quite sung, before you are once again smacked with metal chugging, this time accented with punchier variation. Then they go with their signature move and soar off in the song’s final two minutes.
The point was well made — it makes more sense why a band like Tribulation are opening for them on their latest tour. The dreamy parts on this album work better for me here than they did on Sunbather, and the fact that Clarke’s vocals are not just dialed in with the same old obligatory screams gives this album an edge over Sunbather.
They are true to who they are without pandering to the mainstream. However the mainstream metal community might finally give these guys more of a shot if they set aside their preconceived notion that you have to have a beard and Morrissey hair to give this one a listen.
I was on board for Roads to Judah, a little divided on Sunbather after having it in my iPod for a year, but have no problem rocking this one and think it will stand the test of time more like their first album.
New Bermuda will be released on October 2. Stream the album below. Deafheaven’s New Bermuda tour begins in October. The dates can be found below the music streams.
Oct 15 San Diego, CA – The Casbah
Oct 16 Pomona, CA – The Glass House
Oct 17 San Francisco, CA – The Fillmore
Oct 19 Portland, OR – Wonder Ballroom
Oct 20 Vancouver, BC – Rickshaw Theatre
Oct 21 Seattle, WA – Neumos
Oct 23 Salt Lake City, UT – Urban Lounge
Oct 24 Denver, CO – Summit Music Hall
Oct 25 Lawrence, KS – The Granada
Oct 26 St. Louis, MO – The Ready Room
Oct 28 Minneapolis, MN – Fine Line
Oct 29 Madison, WI – High Noon Saloon
Oct 30 Chicago, IL – Metro*
Oct 31 Detroit, MI – Shelter at St. Andrews*
Nov 01 Toronto, ON – Opera House*
Nov 02 Montreal, QB – Club Soda*
Nov 03 Boston, MA – Royale*
Nov 05 New York, NY – Webster Hall*
Nov 06 Washington, DC – The Howard Theatre*
Nov 07 Philadelphia, PA – Union Transfer*
Nov 08 Carrboro, NC – Cat’s Cradle
Nov 10 Atlanta, GA – The Masquerade – Downstairs
Nov 11 Orlando, FL – The Social
Nov 13 Houston, TX – Warehouse Live Studio
Nov 14 Austin, TX – Mohawk
Nov 15 Dallas, TX – Trees
Nov 17 Albuquerque, NM – Sister ^^
Nov 18 Phoenix. AZ – Crescent Ballroom
Nov 20 Los Angeles, CA – The Roxy
Nov 21 Los Angeles, CA – The Roxy
Tribulation (Official) will be support on all shows
* also with Envy
^^ also with Yob
Black metal made by people who aren’t afraid to admit that they really like Wilco. Top album, this.
I would have gone with “Black Metal made for people who don’t really like Black Metal” myself.
I like black metal. A lot. Not enough to capitalise it when I type it, because that’s stylistically unpleasant, but I love me some blasty horrible.
I also quite like Ride and Red House Painters and Black Rebel Motorcycle Club and Oceansize and The Horrors. Y’see, one of the most interesting things about black metal is the way in which it can absorb and leverage sounds and influences from other genres and still remain recognisable as an extreme genre. Lantlôs did this brilliantly with Pulse/Surreal, examplingly; New Bermuda is very similar.
What’s bad about making black metal for people who don’t like black metal, anyway? New Bermuda undeniably has numerous moments of howling, blast-laden aggression, the guys in Deafheaven clearly know their shit – what would make it into Andy Synn-Approved Black Metal™, exactly? I’m genuinely not trying to be snarky, I just don’t understand the vitriol. It’s not Diabolical Fullmoon Mysticism, no – but what it is is quite good. Isn’t it?
It wasn’t even meant to be vitriolic to be honest, just a little weary if anything. I love Black Metal precisely because it’s a genre that continues to grow and expand regardless of what one might call “external” pressures (in that it’s largely, though not entirely, immune to being commercialised) – partly because its fans are so passionate and will defend the genre against such things, and partially because the whole ethos behind it is one of artistic expression before and above concerns of commercial viability, etc.
(FYI – as an aside, I also quite like BRMC, and saw them when they were but wee lads back in’t day)
I’m actually half-way through a 3-band round-up of groups who are all “Black Metal”, but also all strikingly different. But each one seems, for lack of a better word, entirely “honest” about what they’re doing.
Whereas although I liked their debut a lot, everything since then has struck me more as an affectation than anything truly vital. I’m not saying they’re not still artists in their own way, it’s just that they seem to have identified their target market, and it seems to me to be (largely, though by no means universally) aimed at people who don’t really like Black Metal – whatever its form – but like to present themselves as having “eclectic” tastes. So this sort of sound, which seems relatively neutered and bland to my ears, is perfect, as it preserves a veneer of “edginess” whilst also being nice and safe and palatable.
And I suppose, to an extent at least, I’ve committed a cardinal sin (synn?) there by judging a band by their fanbase… but my perception of the band, both musically, and from interviews and various things I’ve been privy to, is that they are exactly like that fanbase – they know who they’re writing for and who they’re marketing to.
Hence why it seems quite calculated, and why I snarkily dubbed it “coffee-table Black Metal” in another comment discussion.
Again though, nothing out there says it has to be “Andy Synn Approved” (not at all). I just wanted to offer a counter-point really.
And I thank you for engaging with me properly on this. I can tell you now that you’re probably going to like at least ONE of the bands I’m writing about as well.
No one track grabs me quite like “Dream House,” but I think that average quality may actually be higher on New Bermuda than Sunbather. Something I wouldn’t have thought possible, since I would probably rank Sunbather among my top 10 metal albums since 2000. At least certainly of the 2010’s.
After the airy, altogether pleasant sprawl of Sunbather, I love how dark and menacing this record is. Every element of the band is pushed further than before, especially with George’s more varied vocals and Daniel Tracy’s blitzkrieg drum work.
I love it.
This isn’t bad. It’s also not amazing. If you have been listening to Black Metal for fifteen years, this is nothing new. I guess for other people though, they are going to marvel at this. Solid drum work for sure, vocals are meh. Riffs are fairly abstinent as well. reminds me of a lot of different things without really sticking out.
Check out Dawn if you want to hear Melodic Black Metal that will blow your mind, I really think it is that simple. Dawn makes this irrelevant, so the question becomes, why all the hype?
Also, I capitalized BM out of habit, its funny when people read too much into things.
Well, I’m digging this. Definitely darker than Sunbather, which is a change I can get behind.
I’m not the biggest expert in black metal (for the record: with that I don’t mean that I don’t listen any) so I can’t really say on which side of the fence I am regarding whether or not the discussions about this being something new or not and whether it’s ‘objectively’ any good or not; but fuck it, I fucking adored Sunbather, I then backtracked to Roads of Judah which was rad and I am totally digging New Bermuda too.
As for other bands that might or might not be heavy/metal/kvlt/contain clean singing: you guys should review the on the 25th released Blackout Whiteout album from Hanging Garden! 🙂 As a big Hanging Garden fan myself I was a little shocked at first, but overwhelmed by the amazing atmosphere now.
I think I might dig Blackout Whiteout above everything else they’ve released overall, though I can’t help but wish they would be more like the band promised in the song “Ten Thousand Cranes.” I think it’s their best tune by a mile.
Been meaning to check that out. I’ve written about them before.