Dec 172015

NCS Best of 2015 graphic


(This is the fourth of Andy Synn’s traditional week-long series of posts looking back on the year in metal. We’ve previously presented his lists of the Great, the Good, and the Disappointing albums of the year.)

Over the years I’ve moved further and further away from presenting this list as a classic, numbered ranking of albums, and more towards viewing it as a time-capsule of sorts, picking out what I think are ten of the absolute best of the year to represent the absolute pinnacle of the year in Metal.

Of course, limiting it to only ten entries means it’s far from exhaustive in capacity, but I’ve tried – as far as I’ve been able – to give a rounded overview of the past twelve months, embodied in these ten selections which I really think represent the sheer quality and diversity of metallic delights released over the last year.

Interestingly enough, there’s a LOT of clean vocals on the list – by my count there’s a good 6 out of 10 releases on this list which incorporate clean singing, in one way or another, across albums running the gamut from Black to Death to Doom… heck, two of these albums use 100% clean vocals!  (You’re killing me! I hope the paramedics get here soon! — Islander)

There’s also a strong “Progressive” vibe to a lot of this year’s selections, no matter what genre they come from… though there’s also a couple of albums on here which prove that sometimes all you need to be the “best” is to play harder, faster, and heavier than the competition!

Overall this year’s top 10 is comprised of 3 acts from the UK, and 3 acts from the USA, a Swedish duo (not the only two-piece on the list, might I add), a bunch of German cultists, an unbelievably savage Polish ensemble, and one multi-faceted, multi-national collective… and those are all the hints I’m going to give you!


Before we get to the main event though, let’s take a moment to appreciate a few honourable mentions who narrowly missed out on the top slot(s) this year:


Der Weg Einer FreiheitStellar

One of the finest, most intensely cathartic Black Metal albums of the year, and probably the band’s crowning glory.


KauanSorni Nai

Utterly spellbinding from start to finish, Sorni Nai is one of the most atmospheric and moving releases of the year, brimming with melancholy and bleak, depressive grandeur.


MgłaExercises in Futility / MisþyrmingSöngvar elds og óreiðu

Both albums showcase Black Metal at its absolute peak, though they were narrowly pipped at the post for inclusion on this list by another similarly breathtaking example of the Black arts.


LeviathanScar Sighted

Cripplingly emotional and about as harrowing as they come, this is most definitely Wrest’s magnum opus, taking his signature sound to new heights of rage and depravity.


Turbid NorthEyes Alive

A late entry indeed, but one which absolutely deserves its slot. Part Death Metal onslaught, part sludge-caked, sunburnt groove-a-thon, and part Prog-tinged game of sonic twister… it’s the sort of album which could/should/would be massive if only given the right backing and the right amount of attention by the right people. Meaning you.


Now then, with that out of the way… here’s the ten albums which I’ve selected which I truly think represent the absolute best of what 2015 has to offer.


Sarpanitum-Blessed Be My Brothers

SarpanitumBlessed Be My Brothers…

Truly cerebral Death Metal with balls the size and density of a neutron star, that’s what this album delivers.

Technical without being “Tech”… subtly blackened and progressively structured… without being “Blackened” or “Progressive” Death Metal exactly… and featuring some of the most astounding lead playing and devastating drum work I’ve had the pleasure of experiencing this year, Blessed Be My Brothers… is a Death Metal album that resolutely refuses to be pigeonholed.

Bursting at the seams with titanic, earth-shaking riffs, neck-snapping rhythmic shifts, and a seemingly endless series of spiralling, seditiously melodic solos and lead guitar parts, it’s as hook-filled as it is unerringly extreme, and so packed full of creative, unexpected twists and turns that you’ll find yourself discovering new levels and new layers to it on every listen.

Plus it kicks more ass than ten Chuck Norris movies… so what’s not to love?






OutreGhost Chants

This year’s best Black Metal album? I realise that’s a contentious statement to make… so I’m not going to make it (particularly since it’s not the only Black Metal album to make my list). Suffice it to say however that Ghost Chants narrowly fought off competition from both Mgła and Misþyrming (which, truth be told, is probably my personal favourite of the three) to take this particular slot on my list, which should tell you something about the sheer quality of this album.

The fact that the dissonant, dirge-like first track is built around a prominent display of eerie, ritualistic clean vocals should be your first hint that this is something quite special, and as the album blossoms into an esoteric eruption of pure, calculated chaos and rampaging misanthropy, you’ll find that it’s not only something special, but quite possibly a work of warped genius.

The band’s blending of Deathspell-like discordance and pure Polish fury makes for a marriage made in heaven/hell, a caustic cacophony of rippling dissonance and juddering, grating riffs, threaded with black veins of poisonous anti-melody and diseased, dysfunctional harmony.

This is definitely one of those albums that needs to be experienced in person, as words simply can’t adequately convey the raging, convulsive ferocity on display here.





Bell WItch-Four Phantoms

Bell WitchFour Phantoms

As far as titanic, glacially-paced Doom goes, this is most definitely the pick of the bunch from 2015. It’s four songs — each of colossal length and girth (two over 10 minutes in length, two over a massive 22 minutes long) — of crawling, soul-destroying grooves and morbid, funereal gloom topped off with a near-perfect blend of beauty-and-the-beast vocals courtesy of the album’s two members.

Lurching from heaving, brooding, doom-laden heaviness to solemn, bleak minimalism, each track remains utterly mesmerising throughout despite their monolithic size, the duo clearly grasping the importance of shifting dynamics in maintaining a sense of energy and vitality even when you’re bearing down on the listener with all the velocity of a leaking tar pit.

The icing on the cake, however, comes in the form of Dylan Desmond’s elegant fretwork, turning his multi-stringed bass into an instrument of profound creativity, the rumbling hum of the low strings drowning your senses in fuzz-soaked distortion while the high strings weave their own mystical melodic spell, as the songs wash over you, through you, and leave you utterly drained and exhausted in the best possible way.

One of 2015’s most vital, emotionally devastating releases, make no mistake.





Cattle Decapitation-The Anthropocene Extinction

Cattle DecapitationThe Anthropocene Extinction

Taking what might be called “the Behemoth slot” this year – that of an Extreme band who’ve suddenly, by virtue of a mix of bloody-minded perseverance and blistering song-writing, broken through to a wider consciousness than ever before – California’s own morbid sons have produced what may well be the pinnacle of their career thus far (though I know opinions are divided relatively evenly over whether this, or Monolith of Inhumanity, is the quartet’s true crowning jewel).

Flitting between frenzied intensity and bleakly anthemic grandeur, this is a record that doesn’t sacrifice its underlying extreme nature in favour of catchy hooks and big riffs… it simply swallows them, chews them up, and spits them back out again in a hailstorm of blitzkrieg blastbeats and massive, bone-grinding riffs, all melted and mangled together into a series of unflinchingly vicious, grimly infectious, honest-to-goodness Death Metal anthems, topped off with the ever-versatile, ever-visceral vocals of one-man abattoir Travis Ryan.

For once this is an album most definitely deserving of all the hype and attention it’s been receiving, and then some.





A Swarm of the Sun-The Rifts

A Swarm of the SunThe Rifts

The word “crushing” gets thrown around a lot by Metal writers (including yours truly) in a variety of different contexts. From the crushing ferocity unleashed by a band like Anaal Nathrakh at full pace, to the crushing heaviness of a band like Triptykon at their slowest and densest, it’s a word that’s become almost synonymous with the Extreme Metal scene.

But music, heavy or not, can also be emotionally crushing… and that’s exactly what we have here.

Very much an outlier on this list, The Rifts is a brooding, emotive Post-Metal masterpiece of an album, one which builds its momentum and power slowly, layer by layer, constructing a series of bleached-white, post-apocalyptic soundscapes of shimmering keys, echoing drum beats and stark, clanging riffs as it builds towards its inescapable conclusion.

The vocals – sparing and minimalist in their use as they are – are entirely clean, aching with the pain and loss of faded hopes and dying dreams, and at times reminiscent of Anathema at their most desolate and isolated, while the music often reminds me of the early years of the much-missed Altar of Plagues in its bleak and cinematic scope.

Easily one of, if not the, most atmospheric albums of the year.







Probably the densest and most unforgiving album on the list, Antikatastaseis is very much a work of disturbed (and disturbing) art, make no mistake. In fact one could be forgiven for thinking that this was an album of pure madness given sonic form. But beneath the crawling chaos and nerve-shredding discordance there are signs, for those with eyes to see and ears to hear, of a malevolent method to the madness here unleashed.

It’s an ugly, often gruelling, listen… that much is certain… but one which reaps major rewards for the dedicated listener. Significant credit must be given to the impressive clarity of the production, which grants every grating, acid-etched riff and searing, disharmonic tremolo run, ever calamitous chord progression and every twisted, tormented lead part, a sparkling obsidian sheen, without robbing the album of its grimy coating and raw, bloodied underbelly of aural filth.

Perhaps most impressively though, as utterly unforgiving and uncompromising as this album is, the song’s each have their own distinctive identity – they don’t all blend into a morass of dissonance for dissonance’ sake. You can see the edges of these songs, feel their bones and gristle, and catch glimpses of the weird, unorthodox angles that make them what they are.

It’s a challenging listen, make no mistake. But it’s like a drug… expanding your mind even as your body starts to break down from the strain.






Sulphur AeonGateway to the Antisphere

Despite many of these albums showcasing a distinct “progressive” vibe (no matter their main genre), sometimes all you really want/need is a lethal dose of devastating Death Metal at its absolute best… and that’s exactly what you get with Sulphur Aeon and Gateway to the Antisphere.

Every track is a boiling cauldron of seething, roiling riffs and thunderous drum work, packed to the inhuman gills with coiling, leviathan grooves, menacing, razor-toothed hooks, and malevolent threads of deep, dark melody. It’s essentially everything you love about Death Metal in its purest form, all tied together in a nearly perfect package and blessed with the dark lord Cthulhu’s maddening touch.

I hesitated for a little while about including this album, if I’m being completely honest. But when I went back to listen to it again I realised that there’s just no weak points on it. Granted, you can argue that it’s not quite as “progressive” or nuanced as some of the other albums on this list… but does that really matter when it offers some of the most jaw-dropping, gut-wrenching, unadulterated Death Metal delights in recent memory?

I think not.







Yet another album that uses nothing but clean vocals, mut may very well be the under-appreciated British upstarts’ magnum opus, despite the fact that it sees them casting off what remains of their Black Metal roots like a snake shedding its skin.

Indeed, there’s remarkably little in the way of Metal… particularly “Black” Metal… on offer here, as the group have now transformed into what is, essentially, a pure Prog band in the vein of Porcupine Tree or Pain of Salvation at their darkest and most enigmatic.

Indeed, despite this new direction for the group (one which, in truth, they’ve hinted at before, in a more limited capacity), a gleaming shroud of spectral darkness still colours and shades all the songs on mut, the long shadow of their more blackened roots still hanging over the band’s music – though it no longer holds sway over what the quintet have become.

By leaps and bounds the least “extreme” and the least “heavy” (at least in terms of its pure Metal content) album on this list, it belongs here by virtue of being one of the most creative and captivating pieces of work I’ve encountered all year, the product of a band with a true sense of vision and a willingness to follow it as far as it may take them.

And, in its own way, this makes mut as impressive and uncompromising as anything else on this list, and easily one of the year’s best and most intriguing albums.





Akhlys-The Dreaming I

AkhlysThe Dreaming I

The bone-sawing drone of Black Metal’s buzzing tremolo riffs have long held common cause with many of the more Ambient and Atmospheric elements of the musical spheres, though rarely is this strange, often-estranged, relationship as well-realised and well-crafted as on The Dreaming I.

Narrowly beating out the similarly brilliant Scar Sighted to earn its place on this list, The Dreaming I is the corrupted brain-child of Nightbringer mastermind Naas Alcameth, and represents his second voyage deep into the recesses of his own subconscious mind.

The five tracks here blend frantic, skin-stripping Black Metal – all scything, searing tremolo riffs and bone-shattering blastbeats – with elements of hypnotic, ambient horror, combining together into a series of suffocating, nightmarish auditory hallucinations over which Alcameth’s choking, strangled vocals preach their incantations of glorious madness and insanity.

Though the blistering intensity of the album means it makes its mark almost instantaneously, it’s truly a record best experienced in its totality, as a singular piece of art designed to drag you down into an abyss from which you’ll never want to leave.

This is Black Metal with more bite, more brawn, and more brains, than most bands could ever dream of. And that’s why it’s on this list.





Alkaloid-The Malkuth Grimoire

AlkaloidThe Malkuth Grimoire

If I were to pick the No. 1, “best of the best” album of 2015 though, this would probably be it. In terms of sheer creativity, mind-blowing instrumental prowess, ball-busting heaviness, and esoteric, progressive melody, it really can’t be beaten.

Perhaps it’s a little unfair considering that it’s a group made up of some of the extreme scene’s most respected (and feared) names – masterminded and fuelled by the irrepressible energy and untouchable drumming abilities of the legendary Hannes Grossmann – but the phenomenal fretwork and fearless songwriting on display here practically run rings around the majority of the band’s competition.

Complex-yet-catchy riffs, cryptic melodic phrasings, blissful vocal harmonies, gravity-defying drum work, monstrous growls, expressive, intricate bass lines, bulldozing heaviness, experimental and exquisitely structured songs… this album really does have it all, and yet it never feels stretched beyond its means, drawing influences from across the Metal spectrum (and beyond) and amalgamating them all into one cohesive, unimpeachable, whole.

Trust me on this, The Malkuth Grimoire is a true genre-bending Progressive (Death) Metal masterpiece, and you can take that to the bank.



So there we have it. Ten albums which I think truly represent not only the best of what the Metal scene is, but also what it can be… its power and potential and its all-round amazingness.

I’m sure there’ll be some disagreements in the comments section, there always are. But I think (and hope) I’ve made a pretty good case for why each of these albums, though not necessarily my “personal” favourites by any means, deserves to be held up as one of the highest exemplars of our scene today.


  32 Responses to “2015 — A YEAR IN REVIEW(S): THE CRITICAL TOP 10”

  1. Spot on regarding that Sarpanitum album.

  2. I can’t get into Nightbringer or Akhlys for some reason.. same with Sarpanitum. Can’t say I’ve given these records a complete listen through, so that could be the cause. I know some records take an awful lot of spins to appreciate, maybe this is my calling to give them another shot! Outre, Sulphur Aeon and Alkaloid are all top-notch imo, I’m glad they’re getting recognition 🙂

    • I find Nightbringer to be really good black metal that has a tendency to stretch out most of their songs about 2:00 minutes longer than they should.

      • That’s actually a really good way to put it, especially with that Akhlys album (which I’m considering a Nightbringer cousin). For most of each song, I was absolutely enthralled for most of every song, but I found my mind wandering as the songs crept on for a bit too long. Still conjures quite the occult atmosphere when it has you in its grips though.

    • Hmmm… not sure I can help you with that connection.

      Though it may just come naturally over time…

  3. Awesome list!! The Sarpantium album is easily one of the best and most unique death metal albums of the modern age. Same goes with Outre, although maybe not as unique within its realm, but with an unholy flawlessness that should make other bands step up their game.
    I loved Akhlys, but maybe a notch below last years Nightbringer, which really left me speechless.
    Sulphur Aeon are also one of my have death metal acts. And the most.. “basic” isn’t the word, nor is “safe”, because no safe space exists with the non-linear folds of that record, but its about as straightforward as death metal can be, and yet it remands so much more. Gotta be Chtulhus influence.

    • I know what you mean about that. There’s nothing “basic” or “safe” about it, but it’s definitely not as overtly “progressive” as the other albums on the list.

      But, again, it doesn’t need to be. It’s just THAT fucking good regardless.

  4. I found Sarpanitum quite the letdown after the fantastic previous EP. I was hoping for Mithras-ian delights but in the end it seemed like too much emphasis was placed in brutal aspects and was just a bit of a chore to listen to and not very interesting. Same with Sulphur Aeon. I thought their debut was sort of ok, but on the new one the songs all blended into a sort of Portal-lite smear. Listening to songs on an individual basis was fine though.

    Alkaloid I didn’t really get either. Granted that kind of technical prog is not my thing on the first place but it seemed like a fairly sterile journey.

    That Akhlys record was decent. A bit light on songwriting but they covered it well with great sound.

    Abyssal is probably the one I agree with the most. Initially I wasn’t as taken with it as the previous, but it proved to be a decent evolution of the wall-to-wall dissonance of ‘Novit…’

    • Agreed on Abyssal. I found this to be one of my favorites this year, and a really excellent growth on the band’s sound.

      • They’ve come a long way from the (fairly damn decent) Denouement debut. Also nice to have a really top-tier death metal band from the UK. Always felt we were lagging compared to the rest of the world in that area (bar some of the obvious big named ones).

    • Ha, interesting. Looks like we’re basically opposite people!

      Surprised you found Sarpanitum not “interesting”, as I’d never describe it at that!

      I also really don’t hear any Portal comparisons in Sulphur Aeon – though I still can’t decide if I prefer “Gateways…” or “Swallowed…”. Both are fantastic.

      Alkaloid… yeah, just not getting that! Absolutely nothing sterile about it!

      Akhlys… again, not sure where you’e getting the lack of songwriting from.

      And although I think “Antikatastaseis” is the best Abyssal album, I might actually prefer “Novit…” on a personal level.

      • I don’t think the Portal-lite analogy is too much of a stretch. Both predicate themselves on playing a more atmospheric derivation of death metal, albeit less densely packed in the case of Sulphur Aeon. I feel that Portal do much more to distinguish themselves than Sulphur Aeon though, who tend to become unfocussed ultimately more forgettable over the course of an album.

        As for Akhlys, ‘Consummation’ is an ideal example of what I meant when I said that it was a bit tepid on the songwriting front; it’s far too long with little justification for it from what I could tell. A few ideas stretched thin. The rest of the songs were fine though, if never spectacular.

        Alkaloid to me though are very much the ideal of what I consider to be sterility in metal these days. I really can’t stand that production style and, as I think I described it elsewhere, an almost ADHD-like approach to songwriting. For some reason I feel that way about almost everything Hannes Grossmann is associated with, bar perhaps Blotted Science.

  5. Awesome job on list. You took what I believe are best releases of the year and gave great write up. Thank You.

  6. I definitely would put Mgla in the slot that Outre has – the former is probably my BM album of the year. That said, I heartily agree with Kauan (finally delved into that one recently), Code, Der Weg Einer Freiheit, and Cattle Decapitation. I’m gonna have to investigate Sulphur Aeon and Alkaloid a bit more to really put forth an opinion (though I’m inclined to think that your categorization of the latter veers a bit into hyperbole). Also, I really can’t penetrate that Abyssal album, though that kind of DM has never really connected with me.

  7. This is definitely my favourite best of list I’ve seen. Sarpanitum, Outre, Abyssal, Cattle D and Sulphur Aeon were all in my top 10 as well. Good picks!

  8. great picks, Antikatastaseis is so insanely good 🙂

  9. FUCKING THANK YOU. This is the list I’ve been waiting for since these year-ends started rolling out. Finally, someone puts Alkaloid, Sulphur Aeon, Outre, Sarpanitum on a year end list where they fucking belong. Great to see Akhlys on there too.

  10. ‘mut’ wow…that was a curve ball, but it totally sucked me in. Very interesting. Thanks!

    • You’re welcome. It’s definitely a left-field choice in the context of this list, but I really hope more people can discover the band through this.

  11. Some pretty solid picks, found some cool stuff I haven’t heard yet.

    • Cool, that’s one of the big reasons behind doing this list after all. Picking out what I think are some of the “best” releases of the year, even if they might not have gotten the same level of press or exposure as other, bigger, bands.

  12. I know Bell Witch has been featured here numerous times, but I’d never really taken/had the time to listen to them properly. I think I shall remedy that now.

    Also I’d seen Alkaloid popping up on the readers picks and when I finally listened to it, it was not what I expected – but a surprise in a good way!

  13. Much appreciate the list! Had already known about the Alkaloid because of its intellectual lyric content and the phenomenal opening track ‘Carbon Phrases.’ Thanks to your list, though, I’ve come across Abyssal and Bell Witch. Well done! My 15-year-old son turned me on to black and death metal a decade and a half ago. I’m from the Black Sabbath generation, but can safely say if these newer bands had been around in the early ’70s I would have been a big fan. Appreciate your help in widening my personal horizons, there; my son isn’t into this great stuff any longer. A shame.

  14. Whoa, that Turbid North is mind blowing! Not sure how that band eluded me, but good shit. I’m finding lots of great stuff on this list that I missed. And glad to see Cattle made the cut, as it is hands down my #1 for the year.

    • It really is fan-fucking-tastic, no?

      I’ll be doing a Synn Report on the band within the next few months I think, just to give me an excuse to wax lyrical about that album alone.

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>



This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.