Nov 222016



(TheMadIsraeli reviews the debut album by the band Oni.)

Some of you old-timers might remember that I was super-hyped on Black Crown Initiate. I enthusiastically reviewed their debut EP and while I didn’t review their first album, I absolutely loved it. 2016 rolled around, and Selves We Cannot Forgive rolled around and it was… not the BCI I was hyped on. The album was a complete disappointment in fact, and I was extremely, extremely dismayed that the band had already seemingly fallen off the horse. We’ll see what the future holds, but as to what made me lose faith in the band, it was their conversion to a rather directionless, meandering style of songwriting combined with riffs that were barely riffs.

Oni are poised, already, to kick Black Crown Initiate off their own throne where they once brandished a distinctive brand of technical, groovy, yet poppy and melodic progressive death metal. The two bands share many similarities, but with Oni taking it a step further and adding even more influences and elements. I don’t think you can say Oni sound like BCI, but to my ears they have definitely taken the BCI formula and brought it to the next level, whether doing so consciously or not.




Ironshore is Oni’s very first record and it’s an insanely impressive one, maybe the most impressive debut I’ve heard this year. Where Oni differentiate themselves from BCI is that they are more musically technical and have a good deal more energy. Everything is fast and driving all the time. Even with the majority of the music being groove-based there is a sense of urgency and purpose that I have to say BCI often pass up on in order to maintain their huge, stoic nature. Overall, I’d have to say Oni are the better songwriters.

“Barn Burner” and “Eternal Recurrence”, the album’s first two songs now available for public listening are the most tame examples of what you’re getting, and even so they can be a bit hard to digest. “Barn Burner” is an excessive orgy of virtuosity, with dense, low-end grooves and technical math equations translated into fret-board gymnastics.

“Eternal Recurrence”, on the other hand, shows the band’s capacity to craft a poppy metal song that’s still heavy, interesting, and technically inclined. The central riff in this song is undeniably hook city, and the chorus is something that I don’t think you could get out of your head if you tried, with a masterful display of vocal melody versus guitar counterpoint at work.

The album really takes off, though, from “The Only Cure”, a death metal meets Tardive Dyskenesia groove-dozer with vocal assistance courtesy of none other than Randy fucking Blythe of Lamb Of God. His voice lends itself well to the pummeling eight-string riffs and off-kilter grooves.

Whether it’s the eleven-minute epic of “The Science”, the jazz-fusion-meets-math-metal clusterfuck of “Kanvas”, or the melodically imposing giant shadow of “Spawn and Feed”, Oni’s Ironshore at the very least makes them a band worth watching in the future. I’m curious to see where these guys go on a second album.


Ironshore will be out on November 25 via Blacklight Media/Metal Blade Records. Pre-orders available here:

Oni on Facebook:



  7 Responses to “ONI: “IRONSHORE””

  1. Dear No Clean Singing. I wish you would warn your readers up front whenever you break The Rule. Then I won’t be tempted to listen to stuff like this. I’m not saying it’s bad, it’s just that music generally doesn’t interest me one bit when there’s clean singing in it. It’s The Rules.

    May I suggest a tag called: Clean Singing?

    • Or you could’ve done your research and known the band I was comparing these guys to also had clean singing, therefore basic deductive skills would’ve allowed you to process that the music has clean singing in it.

      Also you haven’t been around long have you? We break the rules ALL the time.

      • I’m going to say this as nicely as I possibly can: I obviously don’t know the band you were comparing them to. That’s also basic deductive skills. I generally don’t listen to metal with clean singing, some very very rare exceptions aside, like My Dying Bride.

    • I’m afraid you’ll have to submit your concerns to our official complaints department. They’re open between 4:58 and 5:00 am every third Wednesday. Unless the previous night was a full moon.

    • Actually, we do have a tag for music that includes clean singing. It’s called “Exceptions To the Rule” — and that really is still the rule, even though we do seem to make more exceptions than we used to. I just forgot to add that tag this time, though I’ve added it now.

      • Thanks. Sorry for causing some clutter in the comments.

        • No worries. I have a low tolerance for clean singing in metal myself (hence the name I picked for this site 7 years ago), and the very reason that “Exceptions To the Rule” tag exists is for other people like me who might appreciate the alert. That’s not to say there aren’t well-earned exceptions that we hope people will check out; I made that clear in our “About” section 7 years ago too.

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>



This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.