Dec 262016



(For the third year in a row, we present a year-end list from our Iowa-based guest Ben Smasher.)

Welp, next time we drown in 86 gallons of buffalo vomit, we can think to ourselves, “It’s ok, it’s not as bad as that time we lived through 2016!”

I swear the only reason I didn’t put a bullet in my temple this year was because of all the records that would pile up outside my door in the wake of my departure. Though my rabid interest in metal music had waned somewhat over the last few years, this year I decided to begin a YouTube channel (here) where I talk about my collection and other metal-related topics, and that stoked the fires more than they have been in years.

So I feel that this year I have a more refined list to offer because of how much more time I spent delving into the far reaches of the genre. If you find yourself in the throes of the winter doldrums come January, there is certainly some solace to be found below.



1. Tardigrada – Emotionale Ödnis

I remember this band’s demo from a few years back being somewhat promising, but I never in a million years expected to be here today telling you that this group has released the absolute best black metal album that I have heard in recent years.

What a stunning and captivating debut. This album has it all: It’s melodic, and has those gripping harmonies that we all love, plus terrifying vocals and delay-ridden guitar leads that make you feel like you’re roving throughout the mountains of Transylvania. If I gush any further about this tremendous album I’ll start sounding like even more of an idiot. Phenomenal album.




Vektor-Terminal Redux

2. Vektor – Terminal Redux

With bigger-name bands in metal I usually am turned off by how much it sounds like they aren’t even trying. Here, Vektor has pulled off an album without regard to limitations. While the obvious trappings of thrash metal are the groundwork upon which this band builds their sound, Terminal Redux is Vektor’s distinct and larger-than-life identity in full bloom. I dare say this is a modern metal classic. It’s so melodic, complex, and fantastic that it makes my brain hurt.




Blood Incantation-Starspawn

3. Blood Incantation – Starspawn

It’s time to succumb to the hype. Death metal has a new darling and they are reminding us that the genre some of us had forgotten about can still be played brilliantly. Starspawn couldn’t be more fun and bombastic, taking cues from Morbid Angel, Ripping Corpse, Demilich, and Timeghoul.





4. Wędrujący Wiatr – O turniach, jeziorach i nocnych szlakach

Their first album satisfied with a distinct atmosphere that had already been vividly explored in my mind for quite some time, but hadn’t yet been realized in an album. To have a band match that beloved place in my memory with brilliant black metal was a luxury. The new record sees that moonlit forest revisited again with further ornate details and embellishments, making this record something I will cherish for many years on.





5. Mare Cognitum – Luminiferous Aether

If the election of Donald Trump didn’t make you feel like an insipid homonid who definitely hadn’t been putting enough work into its stupid life lately, Luminiferous Aether certainly will. I have a feeling we are in for several more years of this sort of punishment because this record blows the fence posts off what we think a human is normally capable of, and straight into the voids of space.




Woman Is the Earth-Torch of Our Final Night

6. Woman Is the Earth – Torch of Our Final Night

I was pretty unfamiliar with this band until they pretty much dissolved my skeletal system with their set at the first Hammerheart fest. Then I saw them play newer material at the last fest and I have an even greater appreciation for these brilliant dudes. No other band can be as utterly captivating and delicate with such thunderous might and passion.

Torch is an even more mature and effective utilization of elements that leave nothing between them and your most vulnerable of emotions, stringing them through the album from start to finish.




Darkthrone-Arctic Thunder

7. Darkthrone – Arctic Thunder

I’m personally overjoyed with the change in direction that one of my favorite bands has taken, because after that last album, I had written them off entirely. Obviously, Darkthrone can do whatever they want, but Arctic Thunder invites us to join in on the headbanging fun. Though at times the album seems like the merging of too-disparate genres that do not quite blend perfectly, it’s done as well as it could have been, by the absolute masters of black metal.




Ghoulgotha-To Starve the Cross

8. Ghoulgotha – To Starve the Cross

Ghoulgotha have emblazoned their name on a gnarled but distinct and fetid personality that imbues sweltering, repugnant, and dilapidated death metal with thoughtful and pertinent beauty. Death metal needs more artists like this to walk its reaches further beyond its sometimes stagnant boundaries.

To Starve the Cross is mature, challenging, ornate, and vital. I cannot recommend these guys enough for those seeking something starkly different from the herd.





9. Cantique Lépreux – Cendres Célestes

This year I became much more acquainted with the Quebec scene. With some of it I find myself circling around bands or albums looking for a comfortable entry point, but Cantique Lépreux had me the second I saw the album cover. A vast expanse of moonlit snowy pine trees upon a hillside. You couldn’t make this more inviting if it had cheese and brown gravy on it.

Anyways, this debut is just as confident and stern as any other veterans out there. Atmospheric, frost-bitten, and pummeling black metal with just enough brilliant riffing (those invisible-orange-grasping leads!) to get the message across. Excellent, succinct, and devastating.





10. Cultes des Ghoules – Coven, or Evil Ways Instead of Love

FUCK YES. Displaying more ambition than most bands can muster, this album seriously knocked me on my ass. I cannot believe that someone has pulled off what is essentially a “black metal play”, without abandoning many of the necessary pillars of the genre. What a tastefully done feat.

As I write this I’m still waiting on my copy to arrive so I can’t speak to the actual content of the play / lyrics, but I’m looking out my door for the mailman every hour or so.





11. Vordr – In the Shadow of the Wolf

Vordr is really the only band on my list that I would say is bringing anything primitive to the table. I guess I’d say we’ve all somewhat outgrown this sort of thing, but then Vordr comes along and releases this neck-breaker.

It’s great to hear a Finnish band doing this sort of thing without taking itself too seriously and without getting bogged down by blasphemic rites and that sort of nonsense. It’s been nice to have a reminder that I still need black metal like this every now and then to bang my head until I get a nose bleed.






12. Saor – Guardians

I’ve closely followed this band’s evolution since they were known as Arsaidh and I’m glad to glad to say that Guardians finally feels like the band finding its boldest footing from which to operate. Guardians is inspired, intricate, and vast — vaaaaaaaast. I can see Saor having a lot of lasting influence on how other bands achieve this element of their personalities. The violin playing on Guardians brings so much depth and emotion to these songs.





13. Forteresse – Thèmes pour la rébellion

I’m still becoming familiar with Forteresse, but their latest feels like their mighty step into the limelight. It’s rife with razor-sharp riffs and super-speedy instrumentation at every turn.






14. Stilla – Skuggflock

Skuggflock is such a departure from the norm, I’m tempted to call this a “prog-black metal” album, but that may give you the wrong impression. Stilla have been boldly walking their own path for quite some time now and Skuggflock sees them at their most flourishing moment in their path. I’m very impressed by how challenging and yet accessible Skuggflock is.





15. Lycus – Chasms

Chasms is a somewhat refreshing take on funeral doom because it incorporates tendencies that I identify as being sludge or even drone, depending on your mood. I was unfamiliar with this band until their confident and poised style of doom was too good to ignore. Probably the most accessible album in my list, but it’s a heady and atmospheric nightmare nonetheless.





16. Odal – Geistes Unruh

Holy shit, I didn’t expect another album from this already beloved band, and certainly not one so melodic and aggressive!





17. Eneferens – In the Hours Beneath

Just the massive breadth of styles utilized so cohesively and effectively on this album is something I could get lost in. What a beautiful and powerful full-length from this Montana solo project. I will definitely be keeping my eyes on this brilliant project, who remarkably released two full-lengths this year.





18. Panopticon – Revisions of the Past

Though the time in which these albums were originally released has long since passed, and we have come to enjoy a more refined version of Panopticon, this painstaking project breathes so much new life into what are undeniably wonderful, passionate, and intense albums. I couldn’t be more impressed with how well these were cleaned up. Don’t miss this release if you are a fan of Panopticon.




Old Graves-Long Shadows

19. Old Graves – Long Shadows

Probably the album on this list I pined for the most. After hearing the Paths split and the demo, I saw so much undeniable potential. I still can’t quite put my finger on why, but I don’t feel like this full-length lives up to the potential. That being said, however, this is a great band and I will definitely see what he has in store in the future.




40 Watt Sun-Wider than the Sky

20. 40 Watt Sun – Wider than the Sky

Wider than the Sky isn’t just any album you can approach any old time. This record deserves your undivided attention because it has the capacity to connect with your emotions like nothing I’ve heard in metal. While this really isn’t quite a metal record, it earns a place on my list because it is just an amazing artistic accomplishment.


  1. Great pics!! I must say,however that I have seen a lot of Cultes on 2016 lists but only because of the “leak” as it is a 2017 release and a great one at that!

    • Dude, I thought I had mentioned before that the Cultes des Ghoules album was released in 2016. I received my copy of the CD/book a month ago at least. The February 17 date on their Bandcamp is ONLY for the digital release.

      • My mistake friend! I don’t know why I keep getting mixed up on this! Thanks again. It definitely deserves a top 2016 pick then!

        • I guess it’s because of Amazon and other sites that I see this :

          Product Details
          Audio CD (February 17, 2017)
          Original Release Date: February 17, 2017
          Number of Discs: 2
          Label: Hell’s Headbangers
          ASIN: B01MYUME40
          Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #134,328 in Music (See Top 100 in Music)
          #12260 in Music > Hard Rock & Metal

  2. Great list! Fallen Empire, Dark Descent and Nordvis/ Bindruine can do no wrong.

  3. Very good list, and horns up for the enthusiastic, yet concise write-up for each peace.

  4. Not to be a jerk, but I don’t understand the dismissive attitude towards death metal in these write-ups. Several branches of the genre have seen plenty of great albums in the past few years; it’s anything but stagnant.

    • A simple case of disagreement in my opinion. I find that the expected boundaries of death metal are more constrictive than that of black metal’s and have been since the mid 90’s.

      • I think if we are specific here, it is the classic sound of death metal. Sure, there is an abundance of tech death nonsense. That is not DEATH metal to some though, myself included. DM is more raw and abrasive, think about Obituary. Blood Incantation fits into that sound a lot more than Black Crown Initiate does.

        Again, to agree with Ben here, this is just a difference of opinion.

        • I’m not fond of most shreddy modern tech death, but I have to admit it’s had a pretty good few years that have seen the integration of more melody and atmospheric sounds. Aside from that stuff, you’ve got stellar new material from Ulcerate and Gorguts, and newer bands they’ve inspired like Ad Nauseam and Setentia; the engaging brutality of Wormed; more original dissonant music from Pyrrhon, Artificial Brain, Mitochondrion; bands like Krallice, Imperial Triumphant, and early Abyssal that have pretty skillfully erased the lines between DM and the more dissonant, experimental side of black metal; bands working in an old-school vein like Disma/Funebrarum, Cruciamentum, Dead Congregation, and Grave Miasma, kicking ass with varying degrees of experimentation; nasty murk from Antediluvian, Aevangelist, Ritual Chamber, Chthe’ilist; several promising younger bands in demo stages; and I’d even say the Vektor album (which I love) owes a lot to early 90s prog death, which had thrashy roots as well. I’ve been listening to DM since the early 90s and I think it’s more expansive than it’s ever been.

          I don’t love all of that stuff, and I could certainly understand if it’s not to your taste, but I don’t see restrictive boundaries anywhere.

          • I like pretty much every band you’ve listed there don’t get me wrong, but I still think that even though these bands are putting out great albums, they are still closer to the chest than black metal bands are staying comparably. Take a band like Jute Gyte for example. I don’t think of any of those bands you’ve listed as being as wildly experimental as Jute Gyte.

  5. Many great picks, Vektor and Ghoulgotha among them 🙂

  6. Cool fucking list! Makes me want to revisit some of those albums. Sometimes it takes half of the next year for something to click. 😛

  7. Great List. Election reference is completely unneeded and unwanted and stupid.

  8. Holy Shit that Stilla is good! Great recom. there!

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>



This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.