(We present Andy Synn‘s review of the new album by Sweden’s Dark Tranquillity, which was released on November 20th by Century Media.)
You may have noticed, over the days/weeks/months/years you’ve spent perusing our humble site, that we don’t often cover releases by the so-called “big” names (“big” by Metal standards anyway).
There’s a bunch of different reasons for this – mostly we just don’t think they need the coverage we can provide, so our time would be better spent throwing our weight behind artists who might directly benefit from it more – but that doesn’t mean there’s a blanket ban on covering “big” bands.
However, if/when we do decide to write something about a particularly notable new “big name” release, we tend to wait until after the release date to do so.
Why? Well, let’s face it, any time there’s a notable new record (like this one) on the way, there’s always such a rush to praise or condemn, to be the first to market, the first with the hottest and/or most sycophantic take, that any attempt at a more measured analysis usually gets lost in all the sound and fury.
But by waiting until the dust has settled a bit we’re able to give ourselves more time to sit with the music, to let our thoughts simmer and percolate a little longer, which will hopefully result in a fairer and more well-rounded review.
And, let’s face it, with a career spanning almost 30(!) years, and twelve albums, if any band deserves a fair and honest assessment of their work, it’s Dark Tranquillity.
I have to admit though, after two largely forgettable and mediocre releases in the form of Construct and Atoma, my expectations for Moment weren’t particularly high, especially considering that recent years have seen the departure of both of the band’s long-time guitarists, Martin Henriksson (who left in 2016) and Niklas Sundin (who announced his exit earlier this year).
And yet… for whatever reason (perhaps due to the injection of new blood, with Johan Reinholdz and Chris Amott taking over guitar duties, or maybe just because the band are all on the same general page this time around), Moment just keeps growing on me a little more with every listen, and while it’s far from their best work ever, the version of Dark Tranquillity we hear across these twelve tracks sounds more creatively inspired and emotionally engaged than they have in years.
That being said, I’d imagine your enjoyment as a listener is going to depend largely on how you feel about Haven and (to a lesser extent) Character, as the majority of the band’s twelfth album marries the moody, synthetic sheen of the former with a dose of the taut, tightly-wound riffage of the latter, in a way that – while not wholly original in either concept or execution – works hard to bring out the best of both worlds.
It’s probably worth acknowledging that DT themselves haven’t shied away from making those Haven comparisons either, and while that doesn’t mean that Moment sounds exactly like the band’s ever-divisive fifth album, it definitely shares a similar overall vibe, with some of the riffs and leads even delving further back into, dare I say it, “classic” Melodeath territory.
Take opener “Phantom Days”. There’s an energy and intensity to the guitar work at certain points that we haven’t heard from the band (at least, not to this level) since the early 2000s, while the prominent keys and striking lead guitar work echo the group’s pre-millennial output more than… well, pretty much anything they’ve done since… while “Identical to None” delves even further back in time with some nimble string-skipping riffs and lithe tremolo runs which cleverly tip their hat to the band’s long and storied history.
Similarly, songs like “The Dark Unbroken” and “Standstill” double down on the Projector/Haven era comparisons with their signature synth/keyboard/piano parts and clean/harsh vocal interplay (with both tracks also, to their credit, putting some additional emphasis on the evocative, old school lead guitar work of Reinholdz and Amott), while several of the riffier cuts (including late-album highlight “Failstate”) up the ante and the intensity with a chunkier, more aggressive sound which suggests that the Swedish sextet still have a fair bit of bite left in their bark after all.
Ultimately that’s what sets this record apart from its predecessors… the songs are just that much better, that much sharper, catchier, and more vibrant, from the intricately interwoven synths and riffs driving “Phantom Days” and “Ego Deception”, to the instant-classic chorus refrains of “Standstill” and “Failstate”, to the dreamy, Depeche Mode-inspired ambience of closer “In Truth Divided”, all of which are guaranteed to stick around in your brain long after the album has stopped spinning (something which could rarely be said for the last two records).
Sure, there’s still room for improvement (at 12 tracks in total there’s definitely one or two which could be cut to tighten up the running order and raise the overall average), but, when all is said and done, it’s a simple and sincere pleasure to hear the band actually sounding like they’re enjoying expressing themselves again, rather than simply going through the motions.
So let’s all take a… moment… to appreciate the simple fact Dark Tranquillity’s twelfth album is, undoubtedly, a much needed step up, and a step back in the right direction, from a much-loved band who have (arguably) spent most of the last decade firmly stuck in a rut of their own making.
They definitely took their time with this one, and it shows. Really strong album from start to finish, and definitely an upgrade over Construct and Atoma. I liked parts of both, but they both fell short of my expectations. I’d say this is the best release since Haven.
” I’d say this is the best release since Haven.”
While this is utter, utter insanity… I’m really glad you’re liking it.
Heck, I’m glad I’M liking it.
Then again, I still rock The Gallery and Projector pretty often 🙂
The Gallery remains my absolute favorite. When the female vocals come in, it just sends a chill down my spine!
“Projector” I still love. “The Gallery”… I acknowledge that it’s a seminal album (and rightly so), but I actually think it’s showing its age quite a bit (especially in the songwriting, which is pretty awkward quite a lot of the time).
That being said, I still enjoy listening to it now and then. But I definitely go to “Projector” and “Haven” more often.
You guys like this a lot more than Angry Metal Guy and Ave Noctem did. But I think I agree with your review in this case. Enjoying the songs quite a bit!
Oh, I don’t know how everyone else feels about it – I know one of our ex-writers thinks DT are “boring” (blasphemy) for example, and I doubt this one will have changed his (incorrect) opinion – but, yeah, I stand by this review. I definitely took my time with it, and haven’t changed my mind (in fact it’s STILL growing on me, particularly “Phantom Days”, “Identical to None”, “Standstill”, and “Failstate”).
Not that I’m saying AMG or Ave Noctem are “wrong” (especially since I haven’t read the latter), it’s just that… I’m right, obviously.