(TheMadIsraeli review the new album by Dying Fetus, which is out now on Relapse Records.)
I’m just going to say it. If you don’t like Dying Fetus, nay, LOVE Dying Fetus, you don’t like death metal. I can think of no other band that has better personified the sonic violence, technical excess, genuine anger, uncompromising legacy, and lack of pretension that death metal is all about than Dying Fetus.
John Gallagher has been at this shit now for TWENTY-FOUR YEARS. He’s the godfather of the messy, grimy, seizure-inducing style of tech death, and his sound and approach to songwriting have never been successfully emulated, although no one really even dares to try. Who else is mixing technical death metal, grindcore, NYHC, and slam so well right now? Nobody that I’m aware of, and especially nobody who does it so organically, honestly, and with such passion and dedication.
The Dying Fetus name has never appeared on a bad album. Not one. Not even a mediocre album, or a merely decent album. It’s all been un-compromised, highest-quality death metal, aspiring to heights and depths that not only have been easily achieved by the band but also have rarely if ever been matched by anyone else.
As an album title, Wrong One To Fuck With would seem to indicate that John Gallagher knows this better than any of us. He and his current sickly grotesque metallic nomads Sean Beasley and Trey Williams rule this corner of the death metal game right now. Dying Fetus has been on a real tear since the band became a three-piece. Gallagher lost the entire lineup, and then essentially lost it again. Sean Beasley remained the only loyal member, and after the recruitment of drummer Trey Williams they’ve gone on to write the best of the band’s material yet.
Descend Into Depravity and Reign Supreme, back to back, is a collection of death metal that plateaus far above most of what the genre even offers now. Wrong One To Fuck With, however? It’s the best album this lineup has written yet, the epitome of what Dying Fetus is, distilled down to laser-precise sonic carnage of the most carefully crafted sort.
The mark of a great band, and of musical visionaries, is when you can look at a band’s body of work and see that they’ve ALWAYS been getting better. John Gallagher’s writing, and his playing, have always been getting better. He does crazier and crazier shit, riff- and lead-wise, the longer this band goes on. Sean Beasley and Trey Williams are frankly a perfect fit for the current incarnation of Dying Fetus. They understand what Dying Fetus is at its core.
“Fixated On Devastation” is a fantastic song and it’s also a classic Dying Fetus-style album opener. It begins with some guitar acrobatics and a crazy tapped lead that sounds like the feeling that might occur if your brain were being eaten by fire ants, and then it goes into a fucking filthy-ass decadent groove. No one in death metal does groove like Dying Fetus — the propulsive drive, the hooks, and the rhythmic barbarism stand out.
There’s always been a barbarism to the Fetus sound, though, even in the more technical riffs where it sounds like John Gallagher is emulating brain activity during a psychotic break; they have this unrestrained primal nature about them. Combine that with Sean Beasley’s feral growl next to Gallagher’s signature gutturals, and that only reinforces the vibe. The second tech riff into the primary groove of this song is where it really pulls you in though. Once that riff during the groove kicks in, it really spikes the adrenaline.
“Panic Amongst The Herd” was designed to just smash your skeletal frame into powder. It’s such a grinding song, all the riffs maintaining a chunky, palm-muted emphasis against a drum framework that is constant belligerent chaos. Of course no DF song is complete without the signature flurries of flailing convulsing guitar work, but this song really emphasizes the meaty aspect of Dying Fetus’ groove element.
“Dying With Integrity” is a great “fuck up everything around you” song, and I’m pretty sure it’s going to be a live set standard for them. The NYHC-style breakdown/groove that sets the stage for this song is so sick in presentation, and when it finishes and the feedback swells, you can imagine the “I want to see a fucking circle pit!” call-out before the song launches into its body proper. This is one of the most violent, fast, and intense songs on the album and it feels like it was precisely designed for triggering a circle pit while also having great riffs and being well-written. It transitions from flurry to flurry without relent except for a short groove to give a break before the song explodes into faster convulsions.
That three-song opening salvo is the strongest opening run on a Dying Fetus record that’s ever been. But the album progresses. The music gets into more progressively structured and varied territory. The very next song, “Reveling In The Abyss”, is a roller-coaster ride, with a turbulent opening slam section that’s like having your body dragged across spike strips. The track goes absolutely apeshit with some of the best flurries of technical riffage the band have written. There’s a riff at 3:03 that’s just fucking nasty in that “getting attacked by a swarm of killer bees” way and it embodies much of what makes Dying Fetus great. Moments like that, or the song’s finale, which concludes with an even slower version of the slam that opened it, with harmonized guitar leads, are the kind of moments Dying Fetus does super well.
But I’m not gonna do any more of a track-by-track review. Dying Fetus are in that category of bands for me, like Vader, where the real review is just, “It’s another Dying Fetus” album. Their music is ALWAYS going to be in the upper echelon of the style or styles they are a part of.
Where Wrong One To Fuck With stands in the Fetus legacy and discography is this: It’s the best of the albums in the band’s three-piece era; it shows Dying Fetus continuing the trend of pushing their own envelope off the cliff they stand at the top of. There’s a love and a passion of craft on this album that’s missing on the records of many modern bands (and a lot of tech death especially), and you can feel it in every note, every blast beat, every growl.
I gotta be honest with you, this band is still heavier and more intense than all the 7- and 8-string brandishing deathcore bands and newer tech-death bands out there. Wrong One To Fuck With is just further proof of that.
Despite a goofy as hell title that would be better suited for a Limp Bizkit album than an album from one of the classic east coast death metal giants, this is a solid collection of songs. But I have to say that the new Broken Hope album, “Mutilated and Assimilated”, has earned many more repeat listens and for me personally, it’s a much stronger, more diverse, and more fun album than “Wrong One to Fuck With”. While John Gallhager delivers exactly what I expect from a Dying Fetus album, Jeremy Wagner really stepped up his game and gave me what I consider to be far and away the best Broken Hope album yet.
I’m gonna have to check out Broken Hope. Haven’t listened yet.
I was pleasantly surprised by the new Broken Hope album. Definitely better than I expected and I would agree that it’s the band’s best album yet. But I gotta be honest here, that isn’t saying much. Broken Hope, in my opinion, has always been serviceable-at-best death metal. Not bad but nothing to write home about either. They are not on DF’s level in any capacity.
I just checked out the album for myself after reading Derek’s comment and have to agree. It’s pretty by the numbers tech death with slam elements thrown in and it’s pretty uninteresting to me.
Great write up! It’s a killer album for sure. In the respect of all opinions I do have to lend mine regarding Broken Hope. This style of music is almost as repetitive as Rap. I was a fan of the Band years ago but “Diverse” ? Nobody in that style of music is doing anything to separate it’s self from anyone else. Like I said,I respect everyone’s opinions and everybody likes what they like but mine is that “Tech Death” and “Slam”( lol ), is the trash of the Metal Style.
Good read / Good album !