(Austin Weber wrote this review of the new album by Pyrrhon, which was released on August 8 by Willowtip Records and Throatruiner Records.)
Pyrrhon occupy a unique place in the death metal landscape. From their inception on, they’ve only gotten stranger, darker, weirder, and more unorthodox, after beginning as an already outside-of-the-norm band but one still recognizable in most ways as a purely death metal group in their early years.
The real turning point was 2014’s The Mother of Virtues, a release that really saw them dive into the deep end of madness and experimentation paired with searing and uncomfortable heaps of dissonance. It was an album that even I struggled to comprehend initially, though countless repeat listens helped, as did seeing them play the material live in 2014, which really helped it click for me even more.
After that, they embarked on a series of EPs, simultaneously pushing the improv. and experimental aspect harder, while also returning to a more “digestible” form of death metal for some of the songs. Given that, I had high hopes and a lot of questions as to what their newly released album, What Passes for Survival, would have to offer. But above all, I went into it knowing not to place expectations on it, since Pyrrhon are an amorphous and ever-shifting beast — and this album holds true to that established maxim.
In a way, What Passes for Survival is a much more direct and ravenous experience, by Pyrrhon standards that is. And that’s an important point of distinction to make, since even though it may be more streamlined, the material here is still so abrasive, manic, and unnerving, there’s a good chance it’ll still be too much for some death metal heads. At the same time, the album also continues the group’s collective desire to toy and tinker around with experimental and improvisational ideas. In doing so, they’ve found a way to further both sides of their sound without compromising anything.
That’s an admirable feat, and one which comes about due to the music’s intertwined tornado tangos, between noisey experimentation and complex ruthlessness, which move in a massive variety of inventive and supremely harsh ways from start to finish. While, to my ears, the band have always drawn some influence from both mathcore and grind in their music, it definitely seems that the inclusion of elements from both is more prevalent in the material here than on past efforts. This ends up accounting for what I might dub the more direct, chaotic, and ravenous-sounding Pyrrhon found on What Passes for Survival.
As is usual with every Pyrrhon release, every member delivers an incredible mindfuck of a performance here. It takes a special group of musicians to create music this batshit crazy and be able to deliver it in a way that feels cohesive in spite of being an intentionally jarring and ugly-sounding album. Taken as a whole, What Passes for Survival has the equivalent of about five albums’ worth of ideas in it; this is one deranged motherfucker that demands your full attention.There’s a whole world to absorb within its depths, and I love albums like What Passes for Survival for the unique experience this kind of dense, skronky madness has to offer.The re-play value is enormous, and I’m always picking up on new things with each listen, even after 30 full spins of it easily so far.
Another one of the album’s strengths is the way it ebbs and flows, like a mutated host continually birthing new forms of death and disgust, then letting them wither on the vine and starting over again. It starts off with a strong deranged opening statement on “The Happy Victim’s Creed”, where anguish and genius intertwine to form delicious terror akin to a litany of ingredients re-formed into a singular whole after being chopped and re-configured into a bloody uncomfortable new mass. After that, “The Invisible Hand Holds a Whip” segues into more ferocity, albeit in slightly shorter form and with more of their noisey experimental side woven into its overall aggressive focus in a different way than the opening track’s style of assault.
The hilariously titled “Goat Mockery Ritual” follows next and offers another salvo of batshit intensity and manic angular rhythms colliding and bouncing around in between murky and razorsharp angry riffs while Doug Moore does his best sewer-monster mega-lows overtop the musical trainwreck in motion. An easing back of the throttle and intensity coupled with a dialing-up of the experimental side breaks up the pace on the following track, “Tennessee”, but even that only lasts for the first two-thirds of the song. It eventually culminates in an intricate, mind-melting fury that could be mistaken for the sounds of Satan orgasming while a meth lab fire spreads across the land.
Then after that you get a lot more of Pyrrhon’s frantic and disturbing material on “Trash Talk Landfill”, which kicks off with an utterly grim opening sample before their usual explosive nature takes hold, with this song in particular pulsing back and forth in a quirky manner, like a drunk driver hoping to cause the best of all possible horrific acts of destruction.
After “Trash Talk Landfill” comes the album’s three-part suite, “The Unraveling”, which again breaks up the pace and flow similar to how “Tennessee” did that earlier in the album. Part of that is due to all three of “The Unraveling” tracks being very short and swift numbers that bleed into each other with ease. Although it begins as a warzone, “The Unraveling Part I: Hegemony of Grasping Fears” eventually threads in more of the band’s noisey and experimental elements within its contrasting death metal core. Then “The Unraveling Part II: Free at Last” twists that formula into a more straightforward experience, though no less dark and fucked up to hear. Lastly, “The Unraveling Part III: Live from the Fresh Corpses” caps the three-song suite with yet another different take on miniaturized Pyrrhon madness, distilled to fit a shorter time frame while still kicking your ass.
After those three short songs fly by in the blink of an eye, What Passes for Survival moves on to its massive monster of a closer to give this hellish experience a proper and fitting end. One thing I was secretly hoping for on the new album was a repeating of what that happened on The Mother of Virtues — the appearance of a lengthy epic closer that would distill and warp all their elements into something truly insane. And sure enough, What Passes for Survival has a dreary, passionate, and cutthroat multi-part closer in “Empty Tenement Spirit”, one that vacillates over and over between cold and uncomfortable atmospheric restraint and unhinged warp-speed intensity. It expertly embodies the wounded themes and harsh feeling of modern life that Pyrrhon’s music speaks to so well, but on a larger scale and executed in a more grandiose way.
What Passes for Survival is yet another laudable and intriguing release from a band who continue to push their own boundaries and limits, and those of death metal as well, with their eclectic and cacophonic approach to deconstructing the genre and re-envisioning it in a litany of bold new forms. Every time someone tries to yell about how new death metal is boring, all I can think of is how wrong they are, because bands like Pyrrhon exist, and are doing amazing things that deserve to be praised and pointed to as a notable example of forward-thinking death metal in the modern era.
One of the aspects I love about tech-death is how inhuman it sounds. Impossibly fast/cold/guttural/complex. The ones who do it right hit a zone where they sound truly ALIEN. Pyrrhon, however, never sounds like anything except four guys in a room giving it their absolute ALL and creating music that is seriously fucking powerful in the process. There’s something punk-as-fuck about this band. (And I still say that rhythm section and Moore’s vocals remind me of Jesus Lizard!) Far and away one of my favorite albums this year. Channeling its fury is cathartic for me, and has likely saved me from venting ugly feelings in much less healthy ways, which is one of metal’s most valuable real-world applications. \m/
Well said dude. I think they’re one of the best death metal bands around right now. Absolutely psyched to see them live for the 3rd time next week. If they ever come through your area, don’t miss ’em.
This is one of those metal records that makes me just feel old is hell. This literally just sounds like a mess to me.
Ya I really don’t get the hype for this band at all. Call me old fashioned, but I guess I just like death metal bands that play actual riffs. This sounds like a tumultuous mishmash of pretentious technical wankery to my ears. It saddens me that this is what’s praised as “innovative” these days.
You’re absolutely correct, there are no “actual riffs ” here according to your vague criteria. Personal tastes are one thing, but you seem to be conflating that with the idea of it not fitting your tastes automatically making it “pretentious wankery”. There’s a lot of new bands and releases I feel the same way as you about not “getting it” hype/interest wise. Ironically, for a similar reason, but from the opposite side of the coin: it all sounds like shit I’ve heard before to a damn T. When viewed through that lens, yes, Pyrrhon is innovative. I’m a huge fan of the original death metal wave, but maybe we just have different ideas of what progress in death metal sounds like!