Jan 012018


Happy New Year to everyone!

Our 2017 LISTMANIA series isn’t finished yet, even though the year now is. And really, there’s no reason to think that it should be finished. There’s a decent argument to be made that before you decide which releases were the best ones in a given year, the year should be allowed to end first.

We have seven more year-end lists in hand and ready for publication, and three more that should arrive this week, including two eagerly awaited ones from Austin Lunn (Panopticon) and Semjaza (Thy Darkened Shade). Even if we post two per day beginning tomorrow, LISTMANIA will continue on into the second week of the year. And at some point soon I’ll begin rolling out the Most Infectious Song list.

But today I’ve decided to highlight some Lists of Lists that have appeared recently. These represent the efforts of some hard-working people to aggregate a wide range of Best of 2017 lists, including one master list that’s based on the selections of our own readers.





The first of these Lists of Lists is one created by To the Teeth, whose 2016 master list I also shared around this time a year ago.

To the Teeth is the name of a Facebook-based metal blog that began life in May of 2016. The proprietor, Dutch writer Peter van der Ploeg, regularly posts about new extreme metal songs and full releases, and as the year goes along he adds selected music to a growing Spotify playlist. He also has a Reddit thread in which he often goes into greater depth about what appears more briefly at To the Teeth on FB.

Peter has posted his own personal Top 50 list, which you can see HERE, but he again compiled a “List of Lists”. To do that he began by assembling a population of 75 international year-end lists, which included a lot of “big platform” mainstream publications as well as lists from scurrilous metal-only outlets such as our own; those 75 also included separate staff lists from some sites (such as our own). This year, these were the lists he included in the aggregation process:

Angry Metal Guy (14 staff lists), Anti-Gravity Bunny, Cvl Nation, Decibel, Exclaim!, Heavy Blog is Heavy (general, 3 staff lists), The Independent, Invisible Oranges (11 staff lists), Last Rites (general, 4 staff lists), Laut.de, Loudwire, Metal Hammer, Metal Injection (general, 7 staff lists), Metal Void, MetalSucks (4 staff lists), MondoSonoro, No Clean Singing (5 staff lists), Pitchfork, Popmatters, Revolver, Rolling Stone, Stereogum, The Quietus, To The Teeth, Toilet ov Hell (5 staff lists), Treble, VinylMe.

All together, these lists included a total of 529 records. Peter then winnowed that large mass of releases by filtering out what he deemed “non-heavy” albums that appeared on cross-genre lists, as well as records that were only mentioned once. That reduced the size of the population to 228 albums. And he assigned point values to the selections based on the rankings they received at their original locations. Through those calculations, he came up with a Top 50 “list of lists”.

As I did last year, I’m going to re-post the Top 20 names on To the Teeth’s “list of lists”. To get more details about the methodology, to see the complete ranking of 50, and to read Peter’s thoughts about the outcomes, go HERE (Facebook) or HERE (Reddit).


1. Converge – The Dusk in Us
2. Power Trip – Nightmare Logic
3. Pallbearer – Heartless
4. Bell Witch – Mirror Reaper
5. Mastodon – Emperor of Sand
6. Pyrrhon – What Passes for Survival
7. Elder – Reflections of a Floating World
8. Paradise Lost – Medusa
9. Chelsea Wolfe – Hiss Spun
10. Code Orange – Forever
11. Full of Hell – Trumpeting Ecstasy
12. Wolves In The Throne Room – Thrice Woven
13. Venenum – Trance of Death
14. Ulver – The Assassination of Julius Caesar
15. DODECAHEDRON – Kwintessens
16. Enslaved – E
17. Caligula’s Horse – In Contact
18. Mutoid Man – War Moans
19. The Night Flight Orchestra – Amber Galactic
20. Spectral Voice – Eroded Corridors of Unbeing






On December 1st of last year I did as I do every year and invited our readers to share their own year-end lists in the Comments to THIS POST. Since then, dozens and dozens of lists have been posted in the Comments there; the most recent addition appeared just two days ago, and I suspect more will be added even as we move into 2018.

One of our enterprising followers, Glenn Whitehead, did what I dream of doing every year but never do because I’m too busy and/or lazy: With the aid of an Excel spreadsheet, he counted the number of times any album was included in that big collection of NCS reader lists (a total of 579 albums have been listed to date) and then ranked them in groups according to how many times the album was mentioned. This resulted in 548 groups. At the top was one album that received 15 “votes”; at the bottom was a large list of albums that received only one “vote”.

In a Comment on that post (updated just yesterday), Glenn identified the albums that received at least four votes, and I’ve cut and pasted the results here — with thanks to Glenn for doing the work:

15 votes
Artificial Brain

13 votes

11 votes

10 votes
Spectral Voice

9 votes
Hideous Divinity
Power Trip
Violet Cold

8 votes
Blaze of Perdition

7 votes
Bell Witch
Bestia Arcana
Cannibal Corpse
Der Weg Einer Freheit
The Ominous Circle
White Ward
Wolves in the Throne Room

6 votes
Beyond Grace
Dawn Ray’d
Ingurgitating Oblivion
Rebirth of Nefast
Temple of the Void
The Ruins of Beverast

5 votes
Chaos Moon
John Frum
Yellow Eyes

4 votes
Au Dessus (!)
Burial Oath
Desolate Shrine
Dying Fetus
Fall of Rauros
Gigan (!)
Godflesh (!)
Inanimate Existence
Lantern (!)
Ne Obliviscaris
Paradise Lost
Sun of the Sleepless

In Glenn’s December 31 update to his original Comment, he also identified the albums that received three “votes”, and also provided some impressions from the project as well as his own list of albums that he believes didn’t get the attention they deserved. He named Immolation as his vote for “Extreme Metal Record of 2017” and Havukruunu as his “find of the year” (“An epic heroic massive Folk/Black masterpiece!”).






Heavy Blog Is Heavy did something akin to what To the Teeth did, aggregating lists from various sources and creating a ranked “List of Lists”, which they named “Music Journalism’s Top 25 Metal Albums of 2017“. They’ve done this before, but this year HBIH says, “we have refined our system to something that is much more manageable and also much more representative of the big picture of what “the industry” (i.e. journalistic publications and blogs of note that cover metal music and/or culture) feels is important and stands out.”

None of our own staff lists were included in the HBIH aggregation process, possibly because we don’t count as a “blog of note that covers metal music”, but more likely because most of our staff lists aren’t numerically ranked. Here are the publications and blogs that HBIH chose to include:

Ghost Cult Magazine
Invisible Oranges
LA Weekly
Metal Assault
Metal Hammer
Metal Injection
Metal Insider
Pop Matters
Prog Sphere
Rolling Stone
The Monolith
The Quietus
What Culture

HBIH aggregated these ranked lists according to a methodology they explain HERE, and posted these results a couple of days ago:


25. Artificial Brain – Infrared Horizon (voted for 3 times with mean score: 10)
24. Spectral Voice – Eroded Corridors of Unbeing (voted for 4 times with mean score: 15)
23. Sólstafir – Bedreyminn (voted for 4 times with mean score: 12)
22. Ne Obliviscaris – Urn (voted for 3 times with mean score: 9)
21. Satyricon – Deep Calleth Upon Deep (voted for 5 times with mean score: 15)
20. The Contortionist – Clairvoyant (voted for 5 times with mean score: 17)
19. Immolation – Atonement (voted for 5 times with mean score: 13)
18. Zeal & Ardor – Devil Is Fine (voted for 4 times with mean score: 8)
17. Mutoid Man – War Moans (voted for 5 times with mean score: 7)
16. Kreator – Gods of Violence (voted for 4 times with mean score: 10)
15. Trivium – The Sin and The Sentence (voted for 6 times with mean score: 13)
14. Elder – Reflections of a Floating World (voted for 6 times with mean score: 14)
13. Leprous – Malina (voted for 5 times with mean score: 10)
12. Myrkur – Mareridt (voted for 5 times with mean score: 8)
11. Full of Hell – Trumpeting Ecstasy (voted for 7 times with mean score: 12)
10. Chelsea Wolfe – Hiss Spun (voted for 8 times with mean score: 10)
9. Wolves in the Throne Room – Thrice Woven (voted for 7 times with mean score: 8)
8. Paradise Lost – Medusa (voted for 8 times with mean score: 11)
7. Bell Witch – Mirror Reaper (voted for 9 times with mean score: 6)
6. Enslaved – E (voted for 11 times with mean score: 7)
5. Code Orange – Forever (voted for 12 times with mean score: 7)
4. Mastodon – Emperor of Sand (voted for 13 times with mean score: 7)
3. Pallbearer – Heartless (voted for 15 times with mean score: 11)
2. Power Trip – Nightmare Logic (voted for 16 times with mean score: 11)
1. Converge – The Dusk in Us (voted for 15 times with mean score: 7)


This list was followed by a group of essays about the results, written by HBIH staff members; the first of those (by Eden Kupermintz) is quite critical of what “mainstream” metal publications and sites tell their readers is the best metal, as reflected in the above list of 25. So I guess it’s a good thing that NCS wasn’t included. To read the essays, go HERE.

  5 Responses to “LISTS OF LISTS”

  1. “…[not] included in the HBIH aggregation process, possibly because we don’t count as a “blog of note that covers metal music” …… I guess it’s a good thing that NCS wasn’t included. ”

    Heeehhhhhhehehehe. Healthy shade here. Worth noting that most things nominated in lists (either by me or the staff or anyone else here) didn’t really appear , and HBIH definitely has its niche in some areas. But also yeah, no numeric ranking. Mine was probably the only one you published this year that was numbered, but only the top 3 are ‘ranked’.

  2. Ugh, I usually like HBIH but, the third essay on “Death Metal’s Toxic Nostalgia” got me…. While I feel a few good points were raised, it mostly came across as whiny bullshit, akin to most journalism and movement in 2017.

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>



This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.